These alignments are somewhat speculative. There are only a couple matches, though the numbering lines up fairly well. In any case, until more information is found these alignments should be treated as "thin ice."
(1785) #1, Wilson, Philip
(1791) #2 Carter's Alley, Ledley, John, shopkeeper
(1785) #5, Harr, John
(1785) Hans, John, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #6 Carter's Alley, Lownes, Caleb, iron merchant
(1785) #6, Smith, James B.
(1785) Smith, James, shopkeeper, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #8 Carter's Alley, Jordan, Mary, boardinghouse
(1785) #7, Pursell, Henry D.
(1785) Pursell, Henry, engraver, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #10 Carter's Alley, Van Reed, John, wholesale grocer, also at 69 S. Water St.
(1785) #8, Jacobus, Thomas
(1791) #12 Carter's Alley, Marshall, Christopher, sen., gentleman
(1785) #9, Lawrence, Thomas
(1791) #14 Carter's Alley, Starr, John, cordwainer
(1785) #10, Groves, Widow
(1785) Grove, Jane, boardinghouse, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #16 Carter's Alley, Paxson, Israel, tanner and currier, also at 62 S. 3rd St.
(1785) #11, Santegue, William
(1791) #18 Carter's Alley, Hill, James, accomptant
(1785) #12, Holmes, Widow
(1791) #20 Carter's Alley, Holmes, Hannah, boardinghouse
(1785) #13, Strawbridge, John
(1785) Strawbridge, John, merchant, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #22 Carter's Alley, Nailor, John, cooper
(1785) #14, Young, William
(1791) #24 Carter's Alley, Webb, Robert, jeweller
(1785) #15, Gillingham, Widow
(1785) Gillingham, Mrs., boardinghouse, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #26 Carter's Alley, Potter, Robert, saddler
(1785) #16, McDougill, William
(1791) #28 Carter's Alley, Oliphant, Elizabeth, gentlewoman
(1785) #17, Humphreys, Benjamin
(1785) Humphreys, Benjamin, gentleman, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) (no #) Carter's Alley, Humphreys, Benjamin, gentleman
(1785) #18, Wright, Widow
(1785) Wright, Mrs., Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #32 Carter's Alley, Merriott, Sarah, gentlewoman
(1785) #20, Houck, William
(1791) #36 Carter's Alley, Cregg, James
(1785) #21, Jeremies, Frederick
(1791) #38 Carter's Alley, Roberts, James, cordwainer
(1785) #22, no listing
(1791) #41 Carter's Alley, Lyons, John, barber
(1785) #27, no listing
(1791) #31 Carter's Alley, Sontag, William, accomptant
(1785) #29, Collins, John
(1791) #27 Carter's Alley, Milne, Alexander, blacksmith, also at 72 Dock St.
(1785) #30, Ross, Hugh
(1785) Ross, Hugh, blacksmith, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #25 Carter's Alley, Baley, Mrs., boardinghouse
(1785) #31, Jones, William
(1785) Jones, William, shopkeeper, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #23 Carter's Alley, Porter, James, saddler
(1785) #33, Marshall, Widow
(1785) #33, vacant or residents would not give name
(1785) Marshall, Mrs., gentlewoman, Carter's Alley between Walnut and Chestnut
(1791) #19 Carter's Alley, Marshall, Sarah, gentlewoman
(1785) #34, Kline & Reynolds
(1791) #17 Carter's Alley, Price, Richard, grazier
(1785) #35, Haney, Mary
(1791) #15 Carter's Alley, Hopkins, Joseph, hatter
(1785) #36, Beese, Jonathan
(1785) Beere, Jonathan, merchant, Carter's Alley near 2nd
(1791) #13 Carter's Alley, Beere, Mary, gentlewoman
(1785) #37, Welberger, Peter
(1791) #11 Carter's Alley, Gray, John, tavernkeeper
(1785) #44, Smith, James
(1791) #1 Carter's Alley, no listing
CARTER'S ALLEY, UNKNOWN SIDE
(1785) Clarke, James, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1785) Course, William, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1785) Rerner, Thomas, shopkeeper, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1785) Stanly, William, clerk, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd
(1785) Toy, James, tanner, Carter's Alley between 2nd and 3rd