New Street ran from 2nd to 3rd between Race and Vine. Keys' Alley ran in a line with it from Front to 2nd and Story Street ran similarly to the west from 3rd to 4th; apparently White did not realize at first that these were separate streets, as some listings for New Street (which today does encompass those streets) were in fact on those streets. (See links to those streets at the end of this page.)
Apparently Biddle's numberers also thought Key's Alley, New Street and Story Street were all one street, which today they are, of course, and so numbered them consecutively.
SOUTH SIDE (going west)
(1785) #1, Wiseman, Philip
(1785) Weisman, Philip, shopkeeper, New between Race and Vine
(1791) #38 Elm St., Cripps, George, cordwainer
(1791) #38 Elm St., Yeoman, Sarah, huckster shop
(1785) #2, Waggoner, Conrad
(1785) Waggoner, John, taylor, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1785) #10, vacant or residents would not give name
(1785) #11, Wager, Philip
(1785) Wager, Philip, merchant, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #54 Elm St., Wykoff, Peter, gentleman
(1785) #14, Albright, John
(1785) Albright, John, printer, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #60 Elm St., Cameron, Mary, widow
(1785) #15, Rhein, George
(1785) Rhen, George, brewer, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #62 Elm St., Rein, George, brewer
(1785) #20, Nelson, George
(1785) Nelson, George, merchant, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #70 Elm St., Mason, John, upholsterer
(1791) #70 Elm St., Mason, Thomas, turner, also at 67 Walnut St.
(1785) #21, Painter, Jacob
(1791) #72 Elm St., Benner, Jacob, brick maker
(1791) #72 Elm St., Dullman, Matthias, watchman
(1785) #22, vacant or residents would not give name
(1791) #74 Elm St., Hutchins, Benjamin, merchant
(1785) #23, Lukeberry, Adam
(1791) #76 Elm St., Rockenberger, Adam, porter
(1785) #24, Fistar, Adam
(1791) #78 Elm St., Pfister, Adam, taylor
(1791) #78 Elm St., Pfisters, George Adam, house carpenter
(1785) #25, Garrigues, Samuel
(1791) #80 Elm St., no listing
(1785) #26, Garrigues, William
(1785) Garrigues, William, house carpenter, New between 2nd and 3rd
Also see #29.
(1791) #82 Elm St., no listing
This may well be what Biddle called #86 Story Street (Garrigues, William); as noted above, his listings for
Key's Alley, Elm Street and Story Street were apparently numbered consecutively in the
belief at first that they were actually one street.
NORTH SIDE (going east)
(1785) #28, Hysonclever, Widow
(1785) Hasenclever, Mrs., gentlewoman, New between Front, 2nd
(1791) #89 Elm St., Paine, John, starch maker, Dolley Payne Madison's father; see Jackson, See Philadelphia, p.32. Still standing as of 1937.
(1785) #29, Garrigues, William
See #26.
(1791) #87 Elm St., Stites, John, sea captain
(1785) #30, Stugart, John
(1785) Stukart, John, baker, New between Front, 2nd
(1791) #85 Elm St., Stugart, John, baker
(1785) #31, Howser, George
(1791) #83 Elm St., Hausser, George, porter
(1791) #83 Elm St., Bucher, Jacob, cordwainer
(1785) #32, Troutman, Christian
(1785) Troutwine, Christian, shopkeeper, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #81 Elm St., Bartleson, Henry, house carpenter
(1791) #81 Elm St., Hartman, Peter, labourer
(1785) #33, Smith, Widow
(1785) Smith, Seddalia, shopkeeper, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #79 Elm St., Smith, Sybilla, seamstress
(1791) #79 Elm St., Oat, Jesse, coppersmith
(1785) #34, Eckley, John
(1785) Earley, John, baker, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #77 Elm St., Oexell, John, baker
(1785) #35, Shuler, Jacob
(1791) #75 Elm St., Waterman, Jesse, schoolmaster
(1785) #36, Switzer, John
(1785) Sivitzer, John, taylor, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #73 Elm St., Schweitzer, Jacob, taylor
(1791) #73 Elm St., Wiltshire, William, hatter
(1791) #73 Elm St., McCall, John, taylor
(1785) #37, Heimberger, Thomas
(1785) Heinberg, Thomas, innkeeper, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #71 Elm St., Berger, Michal, cordwainer
(1791) #71 Elm St., Meyers, John, weaver
(1785) #38, Franks, Widow
(1785) Franks, Margaret, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #69 Elm St., Boutcher, Isaac, cordwainer
(1791) #69 Elm St., Kreider, William, house carpenter
(1791) #69 Elm St., McDonnell, William, labourer
(1785) #39, Lennington, John
(1785) Linnington, John, state board measurer, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #67 Elm St., Schreiner, Christopher, schoolmaster
(1785) #40, House, Widow
(1791) #65 Elm St., Allen, Richard, mariner
(1791) #65 Elm St., Lipps, John, taylor
(1791) #65 Elm St., Rush, William, mariner
(1785) #41, Shannon, William
(1785) Shannon, William, clerk to the Northern Liberty vendue, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #63 Elm St., Walker, Matthew, clerk
Note the similarity of profession; was the house a perquisite of the job (if Walker was clerk to the Northern Liberty vendue)?
(1785) #42, Rapp, Frederick
(1791) #61 Elm St., Baker, Thomas, sea captain
(1785) #43, Alwine, Lawrence
(1791) #59 Elm St., Kahmer, William, harness maker, also at 138 N. 2nd St.
(1785) #44, Plym, George
(1791) #57 Elm St., Blum, George, chocolate maker
(1785) #45, Stowse, George
(1791) #55 Elm St., Gross, John, cordwainer
(1785) #46, Wiseman, William
(1785) Wiseman, William, blacksmith, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1791) #53 Elm St., Weissman, John, jun., blacksmith
(1785) #49, Wiseman, John
(1791) #51 Elm St., Dawkins, Mary, widow
(1791) #51 Elm St., Neiss, George, cordwainer
(1785) Adams, George, printer, New between 2nd and 3rd
(1785) Traver, George, porter, New between 2nd and 3rd
There is also one 1785 listing which properly belongs on Key's Alley and ten which belong on Story Street, which White apparently did not know at first were separate streets. See those pages for those listings.