Apparently Biddle's numberers also thought Key's Alley, New Street and Story Street were all one street, which today they are, of course, and so numbered them consecutively.
SOUTH SIDE:
(1791) #86 Story St., Garrigues, William, house carpenter
This may well be what MacPherson called #26 Elm Street (Garrigues, William); as noted above, his listings for
Key's Alley, Elm Street and Story Street were apparently numbered consecutively in the
belief at first that they were actually one street.
(1791) #88 Story St., Vollgroff, Philip, house carpenter
(1791) #88 Story St., Whiteside, Alexander, plaisterer
(1785) #7 Story Street, Smith, Widow
(1791) #110 Story St., Heyler, Sebastian, biscuit baker
(1791) #110 Story St., Krebs, Mary, schoolmistress
A speculative alignment, of course.
(1785) #9 Story Street, Gilbert, Michael
(1791) #114 Story St., Rehm, Michael, labourer
A speculative alignment, of course.
(1785) #10 Story Street, no listing
(1791) #116 Story St., Shafer, Mary, widow
(1791) #116 Story St., Shay, Francis, labourer
NORTH SIDE:
(1785) #19 Story Street, Moutea, George
(1785) Miller, George, labourer, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #129 Story St., Workman, Benjamin, teacher of the mathematics
(1785) #20 Story Street, Hortsman, Theodore
(1785) Hortman, John, cordwainer, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #127 Story St., Ulrich, John, cordwainer
(1785) #21 Story Street, Hamperman, Jacob
(1785) Heppelman, Jacob, cordwainer, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #125 Story St., Bell, Hannah, schoolmistress
(1785) #22 Story Street, Shaw, Francis
(1785) Shay, Francis, labourer, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #123 Story St., Leybrandt, Christian, brick maker
(1785) #23 Story Street, no listing
(1791) #121 Story St., Moutea, George, cordwainer
(1785) #24 Story Street, Thorn, George
(1785) Thorne, George, brickmaker, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #119 Story St., Carr, Barney, constable
(1785) #25 Story Street, Louis, Christian
(1791) #117 Story St., McGee, Robert, lumber merchant
(1785) #27 Story Street, Steinmetz, Jacob
(1785) Stonmeitz, Jacob, brickmaker, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #109 Story St., Snyder, Philip, coach maker, also at 166 Vine St.
(1785) #34 Story Street, Vonphull, William
(1785) Vanphul, William, distiller, New between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #107 Story St., Von Phul, William, distiller
(1785) #37 Story Street, Chew, Joseph
(1791) #101 Story St., Fink, John, porter
(1791) #101 Story St., Weber, George, labourer
(1785) #38 Story Street, Redman, John
(1785) Redman, John, merchant, Story between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #97 Story St., Febiger, Christian, Esq., state treasurer
(1785) #39 Story Street, Freevely, Urban
(1785) Friebly, Aborn, surgeon, Story between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #95 Story St., Friebley, Yorban, surgeon
(1791) #95 Story St., Benno, William, labourer
(1791) #95 Story St., Eckstein, Jacob, taylor
(1791) #95 Story St., Frowert, John, cordwainer
(1791) #95 Story St., Reishler, Lewis, labourer
(1785) #40 Story Street, Garrigues, Edward
(1785) Garrigues, Edward, merchant, Story between 3rd and 4th
(1791) #93 Story St., Clark, Joseph, grocer, also at 152 N. 3rd St.
(1791) #93 Story St., Masters, Thomas, boat builder
(1785) Howell, Samuel, cordwainer, New between 3rd and 4th
(1785) Lapley, Silias, labourer, New between 3rd and 4th
(1785) Lipps, John, taylor, New between 3rd and 4th
(1785) Tivinsey, John, labourer, New between 3rd and 4th