|
Thursday, July 9, 2009
Mendelssohn's Nocturno for WindsChristopher Hogwood's Introduction to the Baerenreiter Edition:
INTRODUCTION
In the summer of 1824 the fifteen-year-old Mendelssohn spent a holiday with
his father in the fashionable spatown of Bad Doberan, on the Baltic coast near Rostock. Writing
home to his family in Berlin he confessed that , although they were "comfortably lodged, and with friendly
people, have a decent piano, pretty view, ... so far I have not written a note" (July 3). Instead, he
bathed in the sea for the first time, translated Latin odes, read Cicero and Homer,
and played the piano at the residence of the Grand Duke Friedrich Franz I of Mecklenburg-Schwerin, under whose patronage the spa (and sea bathing) had grown popular; Field Marshal Blucher,
Wilhelm van Humboldt, Marcel Proust, Rainer Maria Rilke, Queen Luise of Russia and
Tsar Nicholas I all spent their summer holidays there.
It was probably at the residence that Mendelssohn met the members of the court
ensemble, a wind-band (Harmonie)
for which he wrote the present
Nocturno, scored for the classical octet of double winds, plus a flute, trumpet and "Como Inglese
di Basso".' This last instrument was a conical bore, upright relative of the serpent, with
a cup mouthpiece and both open and keyed holes, rather in the shape of a bassoon, which Mendelssohn
described to his sisters as "a large brass instrument with a fine, deep tone, and looks
like a watering can or a stirrup pump" (Letter, 21 July 1824; NYPL).
He illustrated it in a
post-script to his letter three days later (Letter, 24 July 1824, NYPL; see facsimile,
p. X). The
instrument was designed in England by a French refugee from the Revolution, Alexandre
Frichat, and built in London by John Astor; like the serpent, the Russian bassoon
and the later ophicleide, it was used mainly to reinforce the bass line (Beethoven's military
marches have a part for "Contra Fagotto e Bashorni"). Mendelssohn employed it again in his music for A Midsummer Night's Dream (although the published score replaced
it with 'Ophicleide'), in the unpublishedmarches written for the Dusseldorf town band (1833-4)and
in the Trauer-Marscn Op. 103 (1836).
For the Nocturno he appears
to have regarded it as optional,since he refers to the piece as being "fur 10 Blaseinstrumente". Although its part is often taken by a bass tuba today, Mendelssohn appears to have preferred the
ophicleide as a substitute, and
on occasion his friend Sir George Smart transferred such music to an extra bassoon (see
his performance notes in the MS score of A Midsummer Night's Dream in the Royal Academy of Music, London). To give it to a contra-bassoon adds gravitas, but also an octave dislocation which the composer did not intend.
No material from this first version of the Nocturno appears to have survived. According to letters of 1838-9, Mendelssohn gave away (or lost) his
score to someone in Mecklenburg.' In 1826 he "recopied" the piece (we are not told
from what), and this is the manuscript that now survives in the Berlin Staatsbibliothek, dated 27 June 1826 (N Mus.ms. 96). However, the many small "composing" alterations in this source indicate
that it was certainly a revision rather than a fair copy. Thereafter nothing is said
about the piece until 1838, when Mendelssohn decided to enlarge the scoring to a full military
ensemble of twenty-three players plus "Janissarymusic" and offer it to the publishers Simrock, together
with a reduction for piano duet, as Ouvertiire for Harmoniemusik Op. 24 (see BA 9055). At the same time he wrote asking them to publish the Nocturno version which he describes as an "Ouverture fur 10 Blaseinstrumente"
(letter to Simrock, 16 December 1838) and mentions an unknown arrangement for strings
which should be published later - "das Arrangement fur Saiteninstrumente
mochte ich Sie aber bitten (wie Sie auch selbst sagen) sparer erscheinen zu lassen" - but neither of these smaller versions seems to have been
accepted, and the "recopied" 1826 manuscript is the prime source for the present edition.
It is possible that when he wrote the piece, Mendelssohn was aware of Louis
Spohr's Notturno in C for wind instruments and "Turkish
music" Op. 34, written in 1815. More probably, however, he was following the familiar tradition
of wind Nachtmusik from the 18th century
(Mozart referred to his. wind serenades K. 375 and K. 388 as "Nacht Musick" or "Nacht Musique")
where the only nocturnal connection was that they were played at evening entertainments.
The work also reveals an admiration of Carl Maria von Weber's wind-band scoring, particularly
the incidental music to Preciosa (performed in Berlin in 1821) together with an open compliment to his Zigeuner-Marsch of Act I.
Mendelssohn's score gives two parts on one stave for oboes, clarinets, bassoons
and horns; phrasing and dy namics are assumed to apply to both parts, but when the
parts diverge and the slurring is
sometimes uncertain, it has been suggested editorially here with dotted slurs. There are also many repeated dynamics which have been preserved here -
they may indicate the over-zealousness of a youthful composer
or, more probably, the need for frequent
reminders to the local wind-players. The diamond shaped crescendo/diminuendo
marks, <:::::::::=-, a symbol
typical not only of Mendelssohn's notation but that of many
of his contemporaries, are preserved
in this edition (see facsimile, page
VIII, and bars 46 and 67). Editorial markings and additions are shown
by dotted slurs and ties, accidentals
and staccato dots in square brackets, and dynamics
in italic type.
A number of the composer's alterations are mentioned in the Critical Commentar y both for their musical interest and to support the argument
that, despite Mendelssohn'sclaims, this MS cannot be
taken as an exact copy of the missing
original. The flute passage between bars 126-9 is also included,
although it was later cancelled in the
MS, since it presumably represents
the 1824version. For
the 1838 revision, Mendelssohn altered the tempo
markings and added metronome indications (also repeated
in his piano duet version); thus the opening
Andante
became Andante
con moto J =
66 and the Allegro
vivace
was marked J = 152.
Christopher Hogwood
Cambridge and Campagnatico
May 2005
7:13 pm est
|