A Website for Stannie Anderson

Menninger: Where the treatment is people

Home
Memorial Scholarship Fund
Biddle Section, Topeka State Hospital-
Beni-A Wonderful Cat
Bill
My Friendship with Dr. Karl---
Menninger: Where the treatment is people
There's no place like home zoo
How to kill a cat
Stannie Anderson's Obituary
Stannie Anderson's Retirement
The man, Menninger
A message for the editor
St. Patrick's Day in Topeka
Old newspapers never die
Tornado!
I've got my license!
The Skidmore Family of West Virginia
Captain John Skidmore's gravesite
The Skidmore Family Line

by Stannie Anderson

Phil Carson arrived at the C. F. Menninger Memorial Hospital with long hair,

hippie-style boots, corduroy pants and a “roach holder" dangling around his

 neck.

A roach holder, to the initiated, is a holder - perhaps tweezers - used so

marijuana smokers may smoke almost all of the cigarette without burning

their fingers. The last puff of the cigarette is considered by smokers to be the

best part of it.

"People were so nice here, it almost made me gag," he recalled. "A lot of the

hospital staff were religious and conventional. A lot of hippies can't tolerate

this at all, and they leave. They would rather stay with the drugs or go

somewhere else, because it is so hard."

Phil's contacts with LSD, marijuana and heroin had left him in a curiously

stalled attitude. He could drive a car -- but otherwise he did nothing all day

long, all evening long, all night long.

He was belligerent, mixed up. Other psychiatric hospitals, other psychiatrists

had tried to help him but were unsuccessful.

And so he came to the Menninger hospital.

Through the nearly half-century of its existence, this hospital has gained the

reputation of being one of the finest psychiatric hospitals in the world.  Hope

walks its corridors.Phil now fits in well with the more conventional patients at

the hospital.

"I had to make a lot of major adjustments. I’ve settled down quite a bit since

then. Now I feel I can have a decent life."

Phil's eyes were troubled as he talked.

“Often, I’ve wondered why I haven’t killed myself during the last three years

- my life has been so messed up."

He looked absently out the big dining room windows of the Menninger

hospital.

"Every part of this place has helped me. Acid -- grass -- bennies (LSD,

marijuana and benzedrine piils) -- I wouldn't take them now for anything. I

don't need them. I'm a lot happier, and even when I get upset, I don't want to

take drugs."

Phil's first contact with drugs came when he had a job and began to feel bored.

 

He was depressed and tired. He took a caffeine pill "that didn't do a thing at

all for me."

"Then a friend gave me a benny. Then  another friend gave me two bennies.

Once you get into the drug world, you fall into the whole line easily. It's a

closed group and there's always constant fear about the police. It's very

secretive and rather fun in a way to drive to strange towns and wait in car -

interesting- and exciting.

"A friend introduced me to grass (marijuana). It had never occurred to me to

try it.

It was very enjoyable.  I think I'd still find it enjoyable in a way, but I don't

think I want to go through~ all the bother of the illegality and the worry. H

(heroin) is rough stuff. I tried it a few times."

Phil is somewhat cynical about his family's attitude toward his illness.

"I'm not ashamed to be in a hospital and it doesn't bother me. My family,

before I was admitted, kept telling me, 'There's no shame, it's just like

physical illness.' All my friends knew I was coming here -- I told them myself.

It was no big deal to me.

"But my family didn't tell distant relatives for quite a while. People who don't

know me very well have been told I'm in a college in the Midwest. I can't

understand why they do this.

"They've made a great outlay of time and money to have me here, yet it’s not

just I who is sick.  I didn’t do it by myself.

They're sick, too, in away.  Things will have to change when I leave. I can't

go back to being just a little boy.

"I haven't seen my friends for many months and don’t want to see them again,

frankly. My friends really are right here in the hospital. Some will be my

friends for the rest of my life."

There are many public misconceptions about the- Menninger hospital. Through

the years the myths have grown, along with the curiosity of the public about

the cloak of silence that envelops its patients. Often it has been felt that is is a

place for" country club living" for the wealthy and famous; that patients sleep

in luxurious bedrooms with heart-shaped beds and bathe in sunken bathtubs

with gold fixtures.

Often it’s considered a place where movie stars come for a rest between

films and husbands. Or a convenient parking place for teenagers whose

wealthy parents want to go to Europe.

But the truth is far more dramatic than the myths. Some patients are wealthy,

but others have borrowed money to come here.

Some are famous; others are here because they have enough insurance and

savings to afford the treatment. There are no fabulous bedrooms--only small

ones that look like college dormitories. And instead of country club fun-lovers,

there are troubled people who stir compassion.

Debra Simms (names of all patients in this story are fictitious), attractive

young brunette mother of two, several times had been in and out of a quite

reputable psychiatric hospital elsewhere in the United States.

"I remember being taken through the Menninger hospital doors and told to

follow somebody. Then the door was closing behind me. I was following the

man in the real!' Some patients don't believe they're ill.

But I knew I belonged here, somewhere." Much of Debra's concern was for

her children. Would the attitudes of other people about her hospitalization

hurt them?

"Sometimes I wonder what I would think if I were a child and my mother

were off in a mental hospital. I wouldn't see any bandages. How do you

explain a nervous breakdown? Is my mother insane? If she is, could I go

insane, too?

"If you were a child and you have father's brown eyes or your mother's

good legs --and all of a sudden something happens to theparent—you

would wonder, could this happen to me, too?''

Before coming to Topeka, Debra had fallen apart slowly over a five-month

period.

First she took an increasing number of sleeping pills. Then she began to drink

a lot.

More sleeping pills, followed by Scotch.

Debra, upon admittance, found the Menninger hospital would not bar her

children.

It believes the total family is important and that the patient cannot be treated

in a vacuum.

Debra's children soon came to Topeka on visits, ate in the dining room with

their mother and other patients, made some small objects out of clay in a

ceramics group, and listened to the laughing, relaxed talk of other patients.

Then they were sure their mother was comfortable and not locked up in

some awful place.

Debra calls getting well "gutting through."

"Being so sick you want to die and yet having to continue with daily activities

because this is what is prescribed. And there is no let up from it day after

day after day."

"Everybody is strange to you doctors, .nurses and patients. You have no

loving arms to run to. You can't even pick up the telephone and call

somebody who is close to you.

"Many people believe patients at the Menninger hospital are pampered. Yet

within three weeks after my arrival I was tossed into a project group. I was

cutting wood at the woodpile in the middle of January in 10-degrees-above-

zero temperatures, with the wind blowing. And I'm from the South! This

doctor was going to kill me before he cured me" she laughingly said.

"It's been a steady climb upward. I have slowly, at a snail’s pace, over a

period of months, built up the tolerance and coping ability. Every once in

awhile I'll hit a snag and become depressed and feel as I did when I first

came. But it leaves quicker now," she said.

Menninger psychiatrists always squirma little when they hear the word

“magic”applied to treatment at their hospital.

Yet the faith that has grown in the treatment is touching. This 150-bed

hospital has  become a last resort for the mentally ill, a place where people

get well, The Menninger hospital ranks in its psychiatric field equal to the

famous Mayo Clinic at Rochester, Minn.

Like the Mayo Clinic, the Menninger hospital grew from a family

partnership—gentle Dr. C.F. Menninger and his two  brilliant psychiatrist

sons,  Dr. Karl and Dr. Will made psychiatry come alive for the masses

through their vivid books.

The hospital grew from things like Dr. Kari's childhood scary experience of

watching guards march "the wild men" past as He and some young

companions hunted forwalnuts on the grounds of the  asylum at Topeka.

It grew from Dr. Will’s experiences as a general during World War II, when

he tried to find out why some soldiers break at times of stress, while others

don't.

There's a kind of magic in the personalities of these two brothers, and their

warmth and wisdom are part of the fabric of the place.  In a sense, Dr. Will

lives on--and Dr. Karl's touch is everywhere.

The director of the hospital, Dr. Peter D. Fleming, was a graduate in the first

class of the Menninger School of Psychiatry,the largest school for

psychiatrists in the world.  He, too,helps keep the Menninger spirit alive.

A new generation of Menninger’s has come into the picture, Dr. Roy

Menninger, president of the foundation; Philip Menninger,

in charge of development services; Dr. Robert Menninger, in charge of

admissions to the hospital, and Dr. W. Walter Menninger, hospital staff

psychiatrist.

The Menninger hospital uses a team approach. Staff members work together

24 hours a day to help people get well. Somewhere in the hospital - on some

shift - there are sure to be staff members who mean something to the patients.

“The real story in this hospital is one that a few patients here will tell, one

patient said quietly. "You can't walk up to a a patient and ask, 'What’s your

problem?"

And, although I can tell you some things about myself, you won't really know

what I'm talking to my doctor about or what I'm thinking at night when my

door is closed."

Yet this human aspect of the hospital is the one that tugs most at the heart.

Menninger patients - almost as a whole -- are unusually charming and

well-mannered people. Most are highly educated, witty and sophisticated.

They've traveled widely and can talk about books, paintings and music.

Many patients, upon superficial observation, show no signs of mental illness.

Sometimes, with closer observation, the symptoms of trouble become

obvious: An underlying, hard, bright anger; a withdrawn,far-away look;

depression; a too-keyed up gaiety; irritability or trigger-fast frustration.

The Menninger staff has culled the medical records of the past for some

examples of why people come here for help. These cases have been

somewhat disguised, but they are real people:

A 20-year-old man who always dressed completely in black, which he

explained on the basis that he was a believer in Nazism.

A heavy user of drugs, he had attempted suicide several times.

A woman in her late 2Qs, who had a constant need to perform the ritual of

hand washing. A 25-year-old woman who, after the birth of her first child,

had developed frightening thoughts and fantasies and had strange ideas about

being under the influence of other people.

A man who had had an unhappy love affair 30 years before, referred by 

another hospital because of periodic mood swings.

A 56-year-old man who had had a gradual onset of symptoms over the

previous year, which seemed to be connected to promotion to a better job

which promotion he doubted he deserved.

A 23-year-old man who was awkward physically and socially and doing

borderline college work, in contrast to his many brothers who where

extremely successful scholastically and who were all lettermen.

For an idea of how psychiatrists attempt to help patients, let’s take a look at

the case of Charles, a middle-aged married man who gradually developed

fears of being alone, of driving his car, of eating in restaurants, of saying the

wrong thing and of using poor judgment so that he finally was unable to look

after his business.

Over a 6-to-12 month period following the death of his father, Charles began

to develop phobias. The successful head of a demanding business, Charles

hid his illness from his co-workers, who noticed only irritability and

complaints of minor illness that kept him home a lot. Ordinarily an energetic

person, he had lost the old verve.

Charles first developed a fear of eating.

He was afraid he would choke. Then he would start coughing up what he

had eaten, with the terrifying fear, "This is it!"

Although he became afraid to drive a car, he still had to go to work. So his

wife drove him. Charles was quite sensitive to having his wife drive for him,

so he hid his discomfort by sitting in the back seat of the car, lighting up a

cigar and putting his fee up on the front seat.  This made it appear there was a

joke between them as if she’d lost a bet, perhaps.

Fear is a very real thing. Charles would sweat and tremble, with extreme

anxiety.

"What if I were driving with my wife and she suddenly would die of a heart

attack? What would I do? I just can't drive the car," he would fret.

When Charles came to the Menninger hospital, his eating symptoms

disappeared immediately. This distressed his: wife, who felt the illness must

be her fault. But the doctor felt there was no marriage difficulty of importance.

The Menninger doctor, leaning back in his chair, discussed Charles'

problems. "By his food phobia, Charles was saying, ‘I am afraid of sudden

death from some problem with food.' Then one wonders whether the basic

food given to him was prepared by his mother--this might be some problem

he had with his mother.

"The father was a very powerful kind of person strong, forbidding,

frightening, but also much loved. All the children‘hopped to' when Dad said

something--and this included Mama, too. Yet she had ways of getting father

to do things by nagging and yelling. So his mother could handle his powerful

father.

"Then the father died of heart trouble.

Charles foresaw all kinds of terrible problems and feared being battered

between his wife and his mother. Mostly he feared giving in to his mother,

who was older and not in good health, and who could take on this dragon-

like character.  Yet he loved her, too. Although the food phobia left him, a

new one came along to plague him--the fear of heart trouble.

"This had to do with the feeling, 'If Dad only hadn't died and left me in this

predicament, with Mother to handle--' And yet a person really can't be

angry with a dead person, particularly one he loved. So Charles developed

phony heart trouble as a punishment for himself for being angry with

his father's abandoning him to the terrible pressures of the mother. These

pressures, of course, were somewhat exaggerated by the patient."

The doctor noticed the patient occasionally, while reaching for a cigarette in

his left shirt pocket, sometimes took a long time getting it out, as if he were

feeling his heart.

"You're still afraid you're going to keel over and die, even though you have

had as good examinations as any there are," the doctor observed quietly.

"You're still afraid you are going to drop dead like your father.

This then led to discussion of "Why do you think the feeling came on just then?"

"How come you had it all day yesterday until you went to bed?" "Why do

you think you had it only in the afternoon the day before? "

By these questions, the doctor attempted to discover what kinds of things

augmented or diminished the patient’s phobia. In the discussion there is an

interplay of feelings Charles has about the doctor as a guy who knows things

and makes decisions-- somewhat in the father role. By exploring the rational

and irrational feelings he has toward the doctor, he gets to learn a little about

rational or irrational feelings he has about his father.

Charles eventually made a full recovery from his illness.

The start of a new day at the Menninger hospital for activities staff, is at

8:15 a.m. They gather informally around tables, drink coffee and listen to

the morning report. patients do not arrive until 8:30 a.m. Dean Page,

supervisor of the AT department--junctive or activities therapy--begins

reading from a page of notes.

"Dr.---will be out of town for a week and has asked that everyone give

extra support to one of his patients, Miss Garrity,"Mr. Jones has been

restricted to the floor for a few days."

"Mrs. Argan's husband and children are visiting here."

"Mrs. Tyler received a gift package from home and ordered it sent back."

"Mr. Stokes is ‘low voltage’ at this time. His doctor says he should not be

asked to take on any extra responsibility for awhile."

The most awaited news, however, comes at the last. The staff is concerned

about Myra Allison, a 16-year-old who lost contact with reality--or flipped

out--two days ago.

“Miss Allison still is extremely assaultive, requiring several staff people to

assist her in controlling her impulses. She has been talking in rhymes, making

barking sounds, and generally makes a lot of noise—screaming,

spitting and fighting.  Her doctor ordered her put in wet sheet packs.  She is

having special nursing around the clock."

With the wet sheet pack treatment. Miss Allison is immobilized by having

cold wet sheets wrapped around her. For her comfort, hot water bottles are

placed at the back of her neck and feet, and she is given warm tea to drink.

No one really knows why this treatment helps but often it does.  The warmth

of her body quickly makes a cocoon inside the wet sheets, and she feels

protected and secure.

Miss Allison is kept in the wet sheet packs two hours, and then is out of

them two hours, around the clock.

It has been a year since a patient has flipped out to this extent at the Menninger

hospital.  In previous years, before there were tranquilizers, perhaps 50 per

cent of the patients flipped out at some time during their hospitalization.

Miss Allison's illness is noted especially by the staff, because additional

support of other patients now is necessary. Sometimes such an occurrence

can cause severe disturbance in other patients who are shaky. Now the

patients begin to filter in from breakfast, a few at a time, then in a wave. They

get out their projects and pick up where they left off the day before.

Activities are individually prescribed for patients. Some may have a full day of

them; others only one or two. Daytime activities fall into two-hour blocks

mostly. They include such things as a women's service group that sews for

children's institutions in the Topeka area; greenhouse; ceramics; jewelry; art;

personal clothing sewing; project groups for construction of walls and paving

of sidewalks; physical fitness;

manual arts; publications; chorus; men's service group that makes furniture for

other institutions; crafts; and a patient's library.

Younger patients go to the Menninger hospital school, which is an extension

of Topeka High School. Upon graduation they are awarded THS diplomas.

Classes are small and schedules are adapted to the capabilities of the patients.

With the sun streaming through the large windows, the Rosenberry Activities

Building is a colorful, pleasant place. Music plays softly in the background.

Most of the patients have been here awhile, so don't require more than an

occasional word of instruction from the adjunctive therapist - or the A.T., as

 he is called.

Supervising the ceramics department is John Tarlton, a big, rangy man with

what must be the broadest, warmest smile in the world. Tarlton's style with

the patients is easy, practiced and even to the casual observer, not limited to

teaching patients how to make a clay pot.

Tarlton's work is treatment. He's part of the team. Although relaxed, he's

aware and often is able to circumvent a blow-up before it occurs.

Now he sits down at a table at which a number of the patients are working

on projects.

There is lots of laughing banter, "She's screamed all night for the two nights,"

one worried teenage girl said.

“None of us on the floor have had much sleep. I wonder how long she can

go on that way?”

Tarlton's reply is quiet, "Yes, I imagine most of you are a little upset."

"This bothers us." the girl said, "because somehow it is a threat to us. 'We

can’t let it happen to us. Things have been so quiet since we came here.

We've never seen a patient flip out this much before. I suppose we got the

idea that such things don’t happen in a mental hospital anymore." As she

talked, her fingers smoothed an upturned clay pot.

Another teenage girl said, "My doctor told me Miss Allison slept only two

hours out of 48.  It must be terribly hard on her.' Tarlton is listening, saying

little.  He gives support just by being there. He isn’t always this quiet, though.

Tarlton has group of young patients.

“They're wild -- but I'm wild, too!"

he says, with that infectious smile. "I kind of get with them. As long as they

don’t get vulgar or hostile or start throwing clay, I let them go.  I think when

you get too professional, it can be very cold. There is a middle-of-the-road

sort of thing. I think if you're so intense and looking for something all the time,

nobody relates to you."

Tim, a teenage patient, said he hated ceramics and referred to "that damn clay."

He complained bitterly that he hadn’t made mud pies" since he was a kid.

At the same time he was attempting to split the staff by telling Tarlton "what a

bitch" the female A.T. was, and telling what "an S.O.B." Tarlton was.

This young man began turning out mass- produced identical monsters, all with

their tongues sticking out.

"That's the way I feel!" he told the A.T.’s bitterly.

The staff, by working with him to let him know they were  concerned about

his treatment and weren't just trying to make him angry or get in a fight with

him, eventually were able to convince the patient he should destroy all his

monsters. They had served their purpose.

But it wasn't easy for the A.T.'s for awhile.

"He became more confident in us and could talk to us. But naturally, we

wandered,will he lambast us tomorrow? We weren't extra-careful in our

relationships him, but at the same time we tried not  to let some of our own

cuts get opened up.  When he’d say something irritating, we would try not to

fight fire with fire."

Patient government is serious business at the Menninger hospital. Patients

have a direct line to the administration through their floor meetings and the

Patient Council.

Changes sometimes are slow -- but they can happen, and patients know it.

Reported smuggling of marijuana by a patient into the hospital was an

explosive and touchy topic of conversation at recent meetings.

Ordinarily these meetings cover such mundane things as a request for more

bowling trips, a discussion of the proper dress for patients at dinnertime and

the need for additional brands of shampoo.

Faces were serious at the Patient Council meeting. The representatives were

aware of their  responsibility as the voice of the other patients but intermingled

also were their own feelings about marijuana.

For several days the circulated report of the smuggled marijuana had led to

numerous little jokes among patients about "tea leaves." But now the subject

was out in the open.

Staff had asked the Patient Council-and floor meetings-to discuss their

feelings about marijuana.

"God, it scares me to know that stuff might have been in the hospital," one

patient, who had had previous experience with drugs, commented. "I wasn't

offered any."

A few minutes later he asked the council to excuse him.

"I feel quite ill and nauseous ... You see, I had a big trip on some Mexican

pot that led to my admission, and I can almost smell it again."

Then he left the room.

After floor meetings of patients all over the hospital, the Patient Council met

the following week to discuss attitudes.

It was obvious there were many mixed feelings. Most of the patients in the

hospital had agreed that marijuana is not good for treatment. But some also

were hostile.

Many felt it was a staff problem.

Some were angry, because they thought the staff was trying to get them to

promise to tell on each other if the problem should come up.

"You can't tell people they must go and squeal on their friends," one patient

said.

"Some couldn't possibly do it, and it would be asking a tremendous amount.

For others, it is absolutely necessary that they tell, because it would be

threatening to them to have it around. So you can't make a cut-and- dried

ruling about it."

Dances, while often the scene of merriment, still cannot penetrate into the

sadness of some patients.

Sam Darwin recently sat in a pocket of  silence watching other patients

square dance in a blare of country music.

An older, earnest man, he is about the deep-down depression he is to shake.

"I've only been here a few months, he said in a quiet manner that shut out

the music. "I think I'm worse than when I came here. I'm more depressed."

With a wry smile he added, "Then I was up four months and down four

months now I'm up one day and down one day. I'm sure this is an

improvement. "

Darwin, a top executive in a large industry, said his first bout with

depression began during World War II. "My factory had to increase and

I began working 12 to 14 hours a day seven days a week. I became

depressed went into a clinic. I improved. When I went back to work, I cut

down on my working hours. For 12 years I was all right.

"Then the depression came back. I fought it off.  I kept working.  Then I

would lay off work. One day, for no apparent reason, I would wake up and

the depression be there."

Broodingly he watched the dancers and idly twirled the handle of his coffee

cup. "I thought the work and strain caused the depression.  But I know that

it didn't. I'm not working and I'm in a hospital but the depression still is here. I

don't know if I'1l ever be better.

"I can't afford to stay here forever.

People think everyone's a millionaire who comes to Menninger's. There are

some millionaires who come here, but I’m not one of them. If it weren’t for

company insurance, I wouldn’t be able to afford it.

"I'd like to go back to my old job. I know I could go back right now, and my

job would be waiting for me. But I don’t know whether I'11 ever be able to

lick this depression."

With an obvious attempt to lighten the conversation, he joked, "Maybe I’ll

leave here and retire to mowing grass."

The tired, laughing dancers returned the small tables in the dining room to sip

soft drinks or coffee. Many gathered at table with Darwin.

He continued softly, almost as if they weren't there: "I came here for six

weeks, I thought. I came looking for a miracle, and then they told me here

they don't work miracles. It has extended to several months.

And I just don't know."

Now Jim Garton, a successful young lawyer, begins to talk.

"I’d been at Menninger's a couple of months before I began to realize that

I'd been quite close to suicide. I just hadn't recognized it. I’m afraid of such

a depression. He reflected, "Since childhood, it's always been impossible for

me to say ‘no.’

My practice has grown steadily, and it's hard to say 'no.' With all this pulling

at me, I felt tremendous pressure.  Even when I went on vacation and

another attorney was taking care or my practice, I was sure things were going

to pieces while I was away"

He paused, then said softly, "It's hard to be a perfectionist in a perfect world."

"Recently someone asked me to do something in church," Garton said.  "I

was able to say ‘no’ and realize that it isn’t unpleasant at all.

I know now I’ll have to say ‘no' when I return to my practice. 

I’ll have to draw some lines."

"I remember one of the doctors here asked  me, 'What are you hoping to

achieve while being here?' I told him, ‘I want to be comfortable.' I'm not sure

the doctor thought that was much Of an answer. But I think it's the right one.

"I certainly couldn't say I want to be happy, because no one is that, all the

time. Something might happen--there might be a death in my family. Then I

certainly couldn't be happy. But a person who is comfortable is the one who

is able to weather all kinds of things: Happiness, sadness, despair, joy,

grief," Garton said.

Hospitalization is a difficult situation for teenagers, who are aware life is

passing them by. Sue, a pretty teenager with long, shining hair, ordinarily is

supercharged with excitement and brimming with fun. But sometimes the

wistfulness shows through.

"All these activities and parties sound like fun, don't they?' she asked. "But

they're not all that great.  It’s kind of artificial.'

It's hard to be here, when I really don't want to be. I'm 17. I'm young. I want

to have dates. But it's against the rules here to kiss someone or to have

someone hold you."

The word "restriction" can raise the hackles of every teenager in the hospital.

When staff feels the attachment between two patients of the opposite sex is

becoming too great, both may be placed on restriction.

This means they must have no further contact with each other or even speak

to each other. This could last a month--but in at least one case, it lasted two

years.

Psychiatrists are aware of the angry reactions of the patients. But, they say,

getting too involved can interfere with treatment. The rule is "No hanky-panky."

"Patients see a great deal of each other," one staff psychiatrist said. "If they

do become infatuated, it becomes very difficult, because it is hard to be pretty

and sweet  at breakfast,pretty and sweet at lunch and pretty and sweet at

night. They get very frustrated.

If the infatuation develops into something more--

Where they're thinking of marriage it is just a simple point that this relationship

has developed in a very sheltered environment between two people who

are in treatment.  The circumstances are soon traindicated for developing

such a relationship.

"Both people are supposed to be in a state of change. If they're falling in love

with each other one week - and changing -- then the next week they may be

out of love. In addition, there really is little privacy in the building. This is not

the couple's own home, and such behavior can be very stimulating and

disturbing to other patients."

But doctors do want to encourage some healthy relationships, with

opportunities for patients to converse with those of the opposite sex.

"Typically the patient is not really ready for dating,'one psychiatrist said.

They have usually been having lots of dates before

they came here and we were in over their heads-- and without ever finding

it a really rewarding experience.

"There is nothing more distant than a physical relationship without any

emotional experience. We'd like our patients to have an experience in which

they really get to know somebody and share dreams and hopes this can be a

lot more intimate relationship than a physical one."

“There are some feeling both ways about restrictions," one teenage boy said.

"You don't have to be frightened of getting involved in a relationship with

somebody else.

But you’re also angry because you wanted to get involved."

A new trend in recent years in the hospital is the steadily increasing

percentage of younger persons. Currently 50 per cent of the patients are

under the age of 25. The 0'25 Club--for patients over 25--teasingly is

referred to as the "Geriatrics Club."

In the Menninger Children's Hospital, youngsters are separated by sex and

by age.

But in the adult hospital, patients have room arrangements like those of a

hotel, with persons of both sexes living side-by-side. And teenagers are

mixed with the adults. Minimum age for the adult hospital is 15 years.

Unfortunately, not all people who want to came to the Menninger hospital can

do so.

Through the years the fame of the Menninger hospital has steadily grown.

Now more than 3,000 requests for information or admission pour into the

hospital each year.

Letters, telegrams and postcards arrive, although senders sometimes have

mistaken the location of the hospital. Some have been addressed to the

Menninger hospital in such cities as St. Louis, Kansas City, Chicago,Denver,

Wichita and even one addressed to "Tapioca, Kansas."

Dr. Robert Menninger, whose pleasant voice is disconcertingly like that of his

famous father, Dr. Karl Menninger, admits his job in the admissions office is

 "fascinating, discouraging, exciting, frustrating, rewarding, sad, lonely" -- but

"a safe job, because nobody else wants it."

It's an important job, too, because it is here the first contacts are made with

patients who eventually are admitted to the Menninger hospital.

“These letters are a panorama of life-- struggles, trials, tribulations, failures,

heartaches from people all over the world," Dr. Menninger said. "Some are

simply expressed, some beautifully written, most are touching, some clumsily

written and unclear, but they all contain the cry of help in some form and they

all affect us who read them. Every letter, every card is answered personally."

Here's a small sampling:

A middle-aged woman asking for admission to the hospital for her physician-

husband, who has been on drugs and is a "graduate" of 17 different private

psychiatric hospitals in the country.

A letter from a prominent industrial family, pleading for an examination for

their teenage son who, while under the influence of alcohol, held up a filling

station and was arrested.

Parents who write on notebook paper in pencil, saytheir only child had a

mental breakdown 10 years ago and has been in a state hospital all that time.

They just know that if they could get her to Topeka, Menninger's could help

her. They would be glad to mortgage their house, sell their car, borrow from

relatives, anything--if she could come to Topeka for treatment.

“How can I say no, without extinguishing the faint flicker of hope, but I

MUST say it," Dr. Menninger said.

The tremendous faith that people have in the Menninger hospital is somewhat

disturbing to the staff. They fear people will come here with over expectation

about what they'll get. The Menninger hospital may be unable to help. If

people consider it a last resort, this may shatter hope and cause disillusionment.

“We're well aware that we don't help everybody," Dr. Menninger said. "We

don't see this as criticism of ourselves or of the Patient.  From the purely

scientific view, we are interested in what brings about changes.

It’s possible that, after extended tries, we can’t help them then they go

elsewhere and are well within three weeks.

Obviously someone else could and did help."

Ordinarily admission to the Menninger hospital takes time--four months on

the average from the first contact until the patient walks through the door.

In an emergency, he could be admitted within two minutes. But the hospital

feels its first obligation is to the persons on the waiting list.

Usually, a gentle recommendation is made to take the patient to another

hospital "because he needs help now and we won't have a bed for four

months."

The Menninger hospital cannot accept certain patients for some quite realistic

reasons, which Dr. Menninger lists:

The basic monthly treatment cost at the adult hospital is $1,800. This is

$21,600 a year. In addition, a large number of patients get an hour of

psychotherapy two or three times a week--with cost ranging from $30 to

$50 an hour and averaging $35 an hour.

This can raise the total to about $25,000 a year. Occasionally a patient gets

psychoanalysis, which is five times a week.

The basic amount covers all costs of hospitalization other than personal

expenses, such as cleaning bills, toothpaste and similar items.

Not many persons can afford this treatment. The hospital doesn't believe a

family should bankrupt itself--and perhaps deprive its other children in order

to seek treatment that may not help.

So the hospital takes a careful look at whether a family really can afford the

treatment, particularly if it is to be for several years. The adult hospital has no

below-cost beds.

The Menninger hospital is aware there are certain types of patients that it

doesn't do well with: Those with senility; brain damage from an auto accident;

mental retardation; certain kinds of alcohol problems("Alcoholics Anonymous

helps them more than we do"); those really addicted to heroin or cocaine:

The hospital also discourages admission of persons who are in trouble with

the law. It feels it is best for them to serve their debt to society first and then

 if they want some help, apply for admission.

The new patient at the Menninger hospital enters a strange world in which

everything he says and does is evaluated.

"There are people around you every moment of the day," one patient

recalled. "You're spending all your time with the same patients-having

meals with them,dancing with them, working with them in activities. It's a

weird experience when four nurses watch you walk down the hall.

"It's also unusual to be half-awake at night when at about half-hour intervals

the door opens, a flashlight shines--usually in your eyes-and this strange face

peers at you (the nurse, making rounds).

“The staff calls you Miss, or Mrs., or Mr.-and at the same time they are

asking you the most intensely personal questions.

You're forced to live as a family with people you may not want to know

anything about. You are forced into an atmosphere that exactly duplicates a

family--with the other patients as brothers and sisters, the doctor as the

parent, and the nurses running around acting like Grandma or maiden aunts."

The new patient also learns to his surprise that he is expected to control his

behavior to the best of his ability.

One young woman who came here from a hospital elsewhere in the country

was stunned when she learned that she could not scream and cry and throw

herself on the floor as she had before. Group disapproval by patients is

potent.

"We don't like people to act sick around here," one patient said succinctly.

The patient, then, is encouraged to act in as normal a manner as possible and

to cover up the symptoms of his illness except with his doctor.

The knowledge that they'll have a roommate at the Menninger hospital often

is a shock to some of the patients. They've never had to share a room with

anybody. This is not true of all of them, because some have acquired wealth.

But the majority have never had to clean their own room, get the groceries,

or do their own shopping.  Many have had stores bring things to their homes.

After they have made their selection,they send some of the things back to the

store.

So the hospital is a rude awakening for about half the patients share rooms

with another patient.

Even the wealthiest patients at the hospital aregiven an allowance.  This may

range from $3 a week to about $50 a week.  Some patients who go

downtown are allowed only enough money for cab fare and a cup of coffee.

When they buy things in Topeka stores, no cash exchanges hands.

This is handled through the Menninger business office.

When a patient begins to progress to the point that he may be getting ready to

leave the hospital at times to go to college or work, he may be transferred to

Rippel East Hospital, a group of homelike buildings situated somewhat apart

from the main hospital.

These East Hospital patients--almost in a chorus-say the thing they appreciate

most about their situation is the lack of security

screens on the windows. It isn't that the security screens prevent patients from

seeing outdoors. But they do somehow darken the scene a patient sees.

The new patients at first are restricted to the floor--their living unit. While they

are undergoing a batter of physical and psychological testing, they even have

their meals on trays in the living units and work in craft shops there.

This leads to the strange feeling of being locked in, even though doctors point

out, "You're not locked in--the doors are open except at night." But there's a

definite feeling of being trapped.

Locking someone up to keep him from running away would be a temporary

expedience. If a patient insists on repeatedly trying to run away, the hospital

has no choice but to discharge him.

Patients are more likely to be locked out of their rooms than into them. This

happens when staff feels the patients are too withdrawn and need to get more

involved with other patients and staff.

Menninger patients sometimes are restricted to their unlocked rooms.

Occasionally an angry patient will rip off the molding in his room. It can really

look like a shambles, with big black molding all over the place. But with a

little glue, the molding is easily replaced and the room looks fine again.

"It is interesting that even angry patients set a limit on what they do,' the

psychiatrist said.  'There are some things which are not cricket.  For example,

when we were moving a pool table in- one of the lounges, a window got

broken. A patient had only to go out the window to be free."

But then a teenage patient suggested, "Don't worry. We can just put up a

sign, 'No fair out through this window! "

The staff did--and no one went out the window, because that wouldn't have

been playing the game.

New patients have special problems that need airing. The hospital recently

has begun a new patient meeting, with social worker Phil Towle discussing

problems with them.

Patients talk about such things as the shower they're supposed to take upon

admission, thus giving hospital staff a chance to go through their belongings

for pills, sharp objects and other things that might harmful to them or others.

"It seems like an invasion of privacy,"

one new patient said, "but I suppose that's why we're here--to have our

privacy invaded."

"The explanation given to me about having to take a shower was that an

internist was going to do a physical on me," one patient said, 'but I realized

this wasn’t quite truthful,because I didn’t have my physical until two weeks

later.  The staff seems afraid to say, ‘We're going to strip you down, because

you may have pills and hypos."'

There are other universal feelings of new patients.

“This is a timeless place,' one boy said dreamily. "I don't really notice the time

getting better. I like athletics, so I realize time is going by just from the

seasonal sports on television. First there is baseball, then football, now some

basketball games.

When I first came here, I wasn't aware of much of anything. I was kind of in a

daze.

Now I'm aware of waking up in the morning and living through one day-and

then another day."

There also is the fear of striking the wrong note with other patients.

"You don't want to ask, 'How're the wife and kids?'" one patient said.'-

'Maybe there's been a divorce and this would be the wrong thing to say.

Usually small topicshave been eliminated.  You certainly can’t  ask, ‘What's

your problem?' It seems that really the only safe topics for a new patient

in the hospital are: weather, food, where's your hometown and who's your

doctor."

The Menninger hospital treats people with other people. Staff members use

their own personalities in a warm, constructive way to help patients get well.

There's Bill Roberts, acting director of nursing, who admires the example of

Dr. Karl and Dr. Will in believing nothing is impossible and that many other

ways should who can be firm when needed--or if special care is indicated,

"I've got staff that can just smother you."

There's quiet Mrs. Ursula Zimmerman, nursing clinical supervisor, who says,

"Some patients you never forget because there is something very unique or

special about them.

I think it’s because you do some little insignificant thing for them, and

theyrespond. Or you listen to them scream when they're disturbed. When

they get well, they're so grateful for what you did for them."

Big John Mills, a psychiatric aide, can walk into a lounge where patients are

extremely angry and beckon a patient in a non-threatening way. Outside in

the hallway he'll tell the patient, "You're not going to do that." Mills, who

takes great pride in his work, has dignity and professional bearing. He's

a most warm person but can be very firm.

Sometimes he sits for hours at the side of a depressed patient, with neither

saying a word. Then when he gets up to leave, the patient often will tell him,

with meaning, "I’m feeling better now."

There's Agnes Mellenbruch, a nurse who can talk to patients like a tough

sergeant, while at the same time putting her arm around them and giving them

the support they must have.

There's sensitive Minnie Harlow, a group social worker, who wondered why

patients were not using a lounge. She discovered they felt under constant

surveillance because of a nursing station window. Once the window was

covered, the lounge became a popular place. 

There are hundreds of them -- most of them special. And all are part of the

team.

In all, there is a full-time equivalent of 300 people working in the hospital.

"Full-time equivalent" is important, because the hospital does not have a single

full-time doctor, psychologist or social worker. Everyone does something

else, too, such as teaching or psychoanalysis or out-patient work.

The ratio of staff to patients is about one staff member to each patient.

From all of these persons -- every day -- flow notes and observations about

the actions or words of the patients.

Dr. Peter Fleming is at his best when speaking to a group of patients. He's

relaxed and humorous, yet sensitive. Recently he talked to some patients

about notions Menninger doctors have about people - and also about the

unusual relationship between doctors and their patients.

Human beings are under the compulsion to repeat over and over again the

same error or difficulty in living.

“When we repeat unimportant things,we’re not in big trouble.  When we

repeat important errors, we are in big trouble.  It is true of me. It is true of

you.

“Tommy Manville pretty much explains his marraige problems in all instances

to certain  apparently coincidental recurring factors.

“The guy who has had trouble with his math teacher, his mother, his wife, his

boss, the captain while in service, may say he has trouble with people. But

usually if one looks, one sees the same kind of trouble, seemingly slightly

different 1l superficially examined, but basically the same when carefully

examined. He will, come what may, repeat the basic situation here at this

hospital with the staff, and probably most clearly, with the doctor.'

Menninger doctors, he said, believe the relationship  between them and their

patients basically is like that of a parent and child. This is also true of the

relationship between pupils and teachers, between squadron leaders and

airplane pilots, store managers and employees.

Menninger doctors believe each person is made up of a certain basic matrix

which early experiences of a child influence the way he responds to life.

Menninger patients find their doctors fascinating--and irritating. They never

 tire of wondering, "Why is my doctor doing this?" or "Why did he say no?”

“The feeling that a patient develops for adoctor sometimes reaches

considerable intensity so that the doctor sometimes is thought to be the

world's finest, and he can do no wrong.  Sometimes the feelings are negative,

and the doctor is experienced as a dictator,a boob.'

With a merry smile, he added, 'A powerful, plotting, lying fool, to quote a

patient recently."

“If a doctor says ‘no’ to something, he can be experienced as harsh and cold,

or nice and tough and straightforward. And if the doctor is silent, I've had him

called ‘stupid and uninformed’ but also ‘so accepting and non-judgmental"

It’s pretty simple when a patient has only one doctor. But sometimes he can

have two, three, four or five. He can have a hospital doctor whom he sees six

days a week, a therapist he sees two or three times a week, a substitute

doctor in the summertime, a group psychotherapist and he can be seeing one

of the hospital's internists because his stomach hurts.

When there are so many doctors, the feelings of the patient split'and then

there will be the good doctors and the bad doctors. It is possible for a doctor

to be the good guy or the bad guy, and some particular nurse , aide in the

role of the good person or the villain.

“We don't worry about those kinds of things," Dr. Fleming said. "What we

worry about is when no one here means anything to the patient.

"I like it best when the doctor is seen the bad guy; when the doctor is seen the

negative force; when the doctor is seen as the great ‘no' man;, when the

doctor is seen as lacking in understanding and feeling--and the rest of the

personnel are seen as the good guys.

"The simple reason for this is that it's the rage inside of you, the anger inside

of you, the frustration in your earlier lives that we think has caused most of

the difficulties-- and of all of the people trying to help--it is the doctor who is

best equipped to help you discover what is wrapped up in your negative

feelings.

Dr. Fleming touched on a subject that puzzles most patients.

"What most people who are here are asking for, as I understand it, is for help

to live a better, happier, more efficient life.

And they naturally expect that some doctor they consult here will be able to

answer the question of what they should do.

"Shall I divorce my husband? Shall I return to school? And actually, we're not

in the business of giving advice. In those rare instances where advice can be

given, we are glad enough to give it. "But most situations are much more

complex. People, for example, who run out of a marriage only to get into

another one are not ahead. And youngsters, for example, where the advice

is obviously, 'You should return to school,' don't take kindly to such

advice. So that's no help. They know they should go to school.

"What the young patient wants is 'Make me dislike school less; or help me

control my impulses more so I can go to school.'

It is in the concept of the relationship between the patient and the doctor that

impulses can be controlled more, and school or regular; work can be disliked

less."

Of all the workers at the Menninger hospital, none has more impact on the

families of patients than the social worker.

Families have a large role in the treatment of a patient. They must bring the

patient personally to Topeka and be prepared  to spend three to five days in

initial interviews.

Then families return here every month to six weeks for additional three-day

periods, so they may understand what is going on with the patient.

Virginia Heisey, a social worker, says all sorts of feelings are at play when a

family first comes here.

"These include such things as bewilderment, frustration, feelings of fear and

guilt.

They are constantly asking, 'What did we do, how did we contribute to the

problems?'

They are faced with an undeniable fact that something has gone wrong, and

this is blatently in front of them at the time the patient comes into the hospital."

Miss Heisey said it is important to help relatives understand the patient's

problem--which is quite different from causing the problem.

"The relatives are so close to the action that they can't sometimes really

understand what is motivating the action or can't see what the results of the

action are. One of the goals is to help them understand this. Marilyn, an

intelligent young girl who covers her sensitivity with wisecracks and a tough

exterior, says she sometimes feels as though mental patients have a sign on

their backs, "I'm a Nut" or "I'm an Ex- Nut."

"We're not people with four ears or with two heads and we don't like being

gawked at and pointed at and stared at. I think a lot of people still have the

archaic idea that mental patients run around screaming, tearing their clothes

off and banging their heads against the wall.

''But this isn't what goes on any more in mental hospitals.  If you walked

around here, you would think it was a high school or college campus.

Outwardly at least we look like anybody else you see walking the streets in

any town, anywhere. The difference is that we have a lot of fears and a

lot of misunderstandings that we have to overcome before we can cope with

reality and life."

Marilyn's parents have come through a difficult period  in which their child-for

several years--was seen by a number of reputable doctors who were unable

to help her.

“We knew she was having problems when she was four years old. We

thought her troubles were physical. I took her to doctors and took her--until

they absolutely loathed me.

They thought it was I who was the difficult one, the sick one," her mother said.

“Other people thought she was just a difficultteenager and there was nothing

really wrong with her until just before we came here to Menninger's. Same

thought we were just bad parents. Some said we disciplined her too much;

some said, not enough."

Marilyn's illness came at a time when there were some serious physical

illnesses among the other children in the large family.

Marilyn occasionally blacked out and had severe headaches. Often she

would either be too keyed-up or terribly sleepy.

Her schoolwork gradually slid downhill.  In school she would fall off her chair.

While walking to school, she would fall two or three times--then excuse it by

saying she had slipped on ice or turned her ankle. In a sense, she tried to

make herself out the fool by saying, “I’m just clumsy.'"She used to bug me,"

her father said.

'One day she would be sweet and considerate; and another day, meaner than

the cat. It would only take a brief span of hours for the change. Then I

couldn't understand it--but now I do."

"Looking at Marilyn made me cry and ache inside,'  her mother said.  'I

never saw such a pathetic, unhappy child. She was like children in pictures of

bombed-out ruins --absolutely lost and lonely.  She always reminded me of a

shucked oyster--a quivering mass. She disliked herself so terribly--yet there

was this angel child inside--the Marilyn we knew who has so much love to

give and so much concern."

“The psychiatrists we took her to-supposedly tops in their field--couldn't find

the trouble. I think they thought we were a pair of kooky parents,' Marilyn's

mother said.

The showdown came when Marilyn took every pill in the house, in an

unmistakeable appeal for help. The parents turned to the Menninger hospital

as a last resort.

The initial evaluation here was exhaustive.

Doctors found something had been missed through the years in other physical

examinations-undetected diabetes.

But even regulation of diabetes was not the total answer for Marilyn, who still

has problems . For the first year at the Menninger hospital, she spent most of

her time in her room, in bed. She fought constantly with staff and turned her

parents inside-out when they visited her.

Marilyn says now, "I've changed a lot since I came here. I'm happy with

myself, whereas I hated myself before. "I don't think any of us want to be

coddled when we get out," Marilyn added. "We want to get what life has to

give us. Nobody should solve problems for us or hold things from us. Since

I've been here, I know my parents have been withholding some of their

problems. I've told them, 'look, I'm going to be living out there--I want to

know these things now so I can handle them.' Don't try to shelter and shield

us. Just accept us for what we are and not what you'd like us to be."

Marilyn's parents particularly are grateful to the Menninger social worker for

her help with the total family.

“While my wife and I have a fine relationship, we felt we had done a

miserable job as parents," Marilyn's father said. "The children would gang up

and play one off against the other. The social worker made us sit there and

talk it out with her. We got our thinking squared away.

"I think we appreciated most being able to bring our children here to visit

Marilyn.

The Menninger staff worked extremely well with us—not only with Marilyn

but the whole family. This is the only place we have ever gotten the

answers."

Marilyn's mother added softly, "We came here and now we have a child that

we didn't have."

The dinner hour is over, and the long evening begins at the Menninger

hospital. This night there are no scheduled activities, so there are many

patients around.

Phil Rice, a psychiatric aide, watches with increasing intentness as a young

male patient looks through glass of the nursing station at mail for patients

spread out over a desk.

Somehow there is a stark loneliness about the patient -- an aimlessness in the

way he stands, not really expecting to find Rice, lounging inside the nursing

station, cocks his head slightly in an attempt to attract the patient’s attention.

After a few minutes the patient glances up and sees Rice, who points a

questioning finger toward the empty ping; pong table in the hall.

The patient's face lights up in smiling assent, and the two begin to play.

Down in West Lounge the teenagers begin to gather, bringing along their

favorite psychedelic stereo records. The atmosphere is LOUD!  There’s a

sadness among the teenagers. Next week the door in the middle of the

second floor will be closed, so staff will be able to concentrate more on

patients. There's special pain among friends who, next week will see each

other during central activities. But there's still laughter, because, with the

natural resiliency of youth, they bounce back.

Down the hall in another lounge, patients are listening to classical music,

playing cards and writing letters. They're worried,too, about the invasion of

their peaceful kingdom by teenagers.

An older patient--a worried, withdrawn .

look on her face - clutches the collar of her robe together as she walks down

the long corridor.

Three young girls have permission from their doctors to go to a movie at

West Campus, as long as they’re back by 11 o’clock.

Some patients are straightening their rooms.

Others bake cookies for all the other patients. The ever-present coffee pot is

steaming at a hallway table, and soft drinks are in a refrigerator.

A few patients dressed in nightclothes -- with the drawn look of the very

ill- wander up to the nursing station and ask for their medication. The nurse

watches as they take the medicine in her presence and they head  back for

their rooms.

Outside the closed door of Miss Allison, a male psychiatric aide sits on a

hallway chair and reads a newspaper. She lies quietly inside her cocoon of

wet sheets, a female psychiatric aide sitting at her bedside. She rouses

momentarily to say, "I'm sorry I'm causing you so much trouble." The

aide smiles reassuringly. There is silence inside the room, as the young girl

drifts off in much- needed sleep.

The patients are feeling less worried now about Miss Allison, but her illness

still is very much on their minds.

Sitting with the other teenagers in West Lounge, one young girl, who has

been here three years, remembers how it was when she was in wet sheet

packs much of the time during her first year.

''This is a lonely place," she said pensively, looking into the quickening flames

in the fireplace. "Despite all these people, it's a lonely place. But it saved my

life."

 

 

 

 

Enter supporting content here

Questions or comments? CLICK HERE!