The ‘sexually deceptive’ orchid Chiloglottis trapeziformis attracts
males of its pollinator species, the thynnine wasp Neozeleboria
cryptoides, by emitting a unique volatile compound,
2-ethyl-5-propylcyclohexan-1,3-dione, which is also produced by female
wasps as a male-attracting sex pheromone.
Research article by Florian P. Schiestl et al
Article by Elizabeth Penisi in Science Magazine
Strategies of deception are all over the biosphere, and one of
the highest purposes of flexible intelligence is to make judgments
that help us avoid being deceived. Another of the highest purposes
is to help us deceive others. ‘...animal communication is
largely reliable—but that this basic reliability also allows the
clever deceiver to flourish.’
Book by William Searcy and Stephen Nowicki
20 August 2008
Religio laici
In this extended poetic investigation, John Dryden seeks to justify
his
Christian faith in the context of ancient animist religions as well as the
non-denominational ‘Deism’ that is the fashion of intellectuals of his
era. Here is the conclusion at which he arrives, espousing
tolerance, a non-confrontational deportment, and humility in the face all that we do not know:
What then remains, but, waving each extreme,
The tides of ignorance, and pride to stem?
Neither so rich a treasure to forego;
Nor proudly seek beyond our pow’r to know:
Faith is not built on disquisitions vain;
The things we must believe, are few, and plain:
But since men will believe more than they need;
And every man will make himself a creed:
In doubtful questions ’tis the safest way
To learn what unsuspected ancients say:
For ’tis not likely we should higher soar
In search of Heav’n, than all the Church before:
Nor can we be deceiv’d, unless we see
The Scripture, and the Fathers disagree.
If after all, they stand suspected still,
(For no man’s faith depends upon his will
’Tis some relief, that points not clearly known,
Without much hazard may be let alone:
And, after hearing what our Church can say,
If still our reason runs another way,
That private reason ’tis more just to curb,
Than by disputes the public peace disturb:
For points obscure are of small use to learn:
But common quiet is mankind’s concern.
— John Henry Dryden, born this day in 1631
19 August 2008
The blame-China syndrome
It’s open season on China, newly installed as the world’s largest
emitter of carbon dioxide. Last week the Netherlands Environmental
Assessment Agency said China’
s economy was responsible for two-thirds of
the global increase in CO2 emissions last year. The week
before, the environment group WWF calculated that China uses 15 per cent
of the world’s resources. It builds two coal-fired power stations a
week, manufactures half the world’s cement and is the world’s largest
importer of tropical timber.
The charge sheet is long, and mostly true. But remember that 1 in every
5 of the planet’s citizens is Chinese. Looked at in this light, the
stats do not look half as bad. On average, the CO2 emissions
of a Chinese person are half those of a European and a quarter those of
an American or Australian. Per capita, China’s ecological footprint is
below the world average.
Yes, China burns a lot of coal. But last year it also deployed more wind
turbines than any other country. Its recycling businesses are among the
world’s largest. It leads the world in aquaculture, helping to protect
surviving ocean fisheries.
Should we at least blame China for its huge population? Go carefully.
Its population would be much higher but for its sometimes coercive
efforts to cut birth rates. Ah yes, China’s dodgy human rights record.
We don’t like that either. Rightly so, perhaps. But we can’t have it all
ways.
One day you will awaken and see that your whole previous life was as a dream or hallucination.
It will not be, “I can’t believe I spent my time working for money to buy a bigger car.”
More like, “I can’t narrow my vision now to 3 dimensions, but I remember that for decades it seemed
to me that’s all that there was.”
Or perhaps, “As I remember it, it seemed to me that I spent my whole life worrying that I might die.”
— Josh Mitteldorf
17 August 2008
We decide what is important while we are asleep
‘Sleep is a smart, sophisticated process. You might say that sleep is
actually working at night to decide what memories to hold on to and what
to let go of.’
— Jessica Payne
Many experiments have established the role of sleep in consolidating
memories. A new Harvard Med School study just published in
Psychological Science suggests that memories are filtered for
emotional content while we sleep, and the ones that have moved
us are selectively retained.
Alan Wall
speaks of paranoia as the psychic force animating the mythology of our
time. ‘Is there a fundamental link, in the era of modernity at
any rate, between the paranoid and the poetic?’ We transform horror and
the unbearable sadness of loss — visions that threaten to isolate and
destroy us — into myths that pull us together.
‘The Warren Report on the Kennedy assassination might be taken as
one of the founding texts of American paranoid fiction. It opened a gap
between information and credibility into which the fiction and the irony
have never ceased rushing ever since. The present status of the
commissions and reports into 9/11 doesn’t give much hope that they will
do more than fill a parallel slot in the psyche.’
Marina Warner nominates candidates for myths to embody our fears for
the future of our planet.
It seems to me that Erichsychthon makes a strong candidate in the
world of eco-disaster: he’s the tycoon in Ovid who cuts down a whole
forest even after he has been warned of the consequences, and is then
cursed by the outraged goddess of nature with unappeasable hunger; he
ends up selling his daughter for food, and when that no longer works,
consuming himself bite by bite.
Other myths of our time could be the wanderers and fugitives – Io chased
from country to country; Leto forbidden from resting anywhere to give
birth to her children; Aeneas leaving Troy in burning ruins with his
father on his back, like Dido leaving Tyre, both of them fleeing
westwards.
Last year, the most recently discovered planet, ‘2003-UB313’, was
renamed Eris after the Goddess of Strife, whose actions catalyse the
Trojan War....However, it turns out
that astronomers weren’t inspired to this choice by the state of the
world, but by the state of their profession. In a spirit of resistance
to Eris’s planetary hold, I hope another body is orbiting into view,
dreamed up by a fabulist’s reasoned imagination and bringing with it new
creatures out of the mirror of myth.
15 August 2008
On water’s meaning
... he scissors the waterscape apart
And sways it to tatters. Its coldness
Holding him to itself, he grants the grasp,
For to swim is also to take hold
On water’s meaning, to move in its embrace
And to be, between grasp and grasping, free.
“Habitualization devours works, clothes, furniture, one’s wife, and
the fear of war. … And art exists that one may recover the sensation of
life; it exists to make one feel things, to make the stone stony. The purpose of art is to impart the sensation of things as they are
perceived and not as they are known. The technique of art is to make
objects ‘unfamiliar’, to make forms difficult, to increase the
difficulty and length of perception because the process of perception is
an aesthetic end in itself and must be prolonged. Art is a way of
experiencing the artfulness of an object; the object is not important.”
It’
s the source of your original contribution to your community and
to those you love. It’s the essential ‘you’. Whatever
it takes to keep that part of you healthy and active is what you must do
for yourself.
Then you must give it time. Make your appointment with the
muse. Keep it faithfully, even when your muse is in hiding.
— Josh Mitteldorf
12 August 2008
Democracy in China
HONG KONG - While China’s crackdown on Tibet and
heavy-handed approach to dissidents in general have reinforced its
international image as a ruthless, totalitarian state ahead of next
month’s Summer Olympic Games, the reality on the ground is that the
Middle Kingdom has never been more democratic and is, step by small
step, becoming even more so.
That reality was bolstered with the recent announcement by the Chinese
Communist Party (CCP), as reported by the official Xinhua News Agency,
that it has adopted a ‘tenure system’ that will give real power to
traditionally rubber-stamp delegates to party congresses. In the past,
party elites made all the decisions. The future could be quite different
— but that all depends on implementation of the new system...
The great difference between the dictator Mao and those currently
wielding power, however, is that today’s leadership understands that,
without democratic reform, the country risks widespread social unrest
that could ultimately bring down the party.
How is the war going really? I want your honest opinion.
Charles A Dana, born this day in 1819, was a fiercely independent
journalist during the Civil War, who followed General Grant and reported
his monstrous errors of judgment along with his brilliant successes.
It is a striking contrast to modern political practice that Dana had
direct access to President Lincoln. His telegraphed dispatches
from the front lines were eagerly received in the White House, and
Lincoln valued his unvarnished observations. Very late in the war,
Dana was appointed to an official capacity as Under-secretary of War, as
he continued the same reportage with a new title.
A close confidant of Ulysses Grant, Dana supported his Presidential
campaign, but later revealed his problems with alcohol to the public,
and ruthlessly criticized Grant’s failings as President.
‘Fight for your opinions, but do not believe that they contain the
whole truth or the only truth.’
— Charles Anderson Dana (1819-1897)
8 August 2008
Sojourns in the Parallel World
We live our lives of human passions,
cruelties, dreams, concepts,
crimes and the exercise of virtue
in and beside a world devoid
of our preoccupations, free
from apprehension -- though affected,
certainly, by our actions. A world
parallel to our own though overlapping.
We call it “Nature”; only reluctantly
admitting ourselves to be “Nature” too.
Whenever we lose track of our own obsessions,
our self-concerns, because we drift for a minute,
an hour even, of pure (almost pure)
response to that insouciant life:
cloud, bird, fox, the flow of light, the dancing
pilgrimage of water, vast stillness
of spellbound ephemerae on a lit windowpane,
animal voices, mineral hum, wind
conversing with rain, ocean with rock, stuttering
of fire to coal--then something tethered
in us, hobbled like a donkey on its patch
of gnawed grass and thistles, breaks free.
No one discovers
just where we’ve been, when we’re caught up again
into our own sphere (where we must
return, indeed, to evolve our destinies)
-- but we have changed, a little.
May we not imagine that possibly this earthly life of
ours is to the other life what sleep is to waking? May not all our
life be a dream and death an awakening? But an awakening to what?
And supposing everything is but the dream of God and that God one day
will awake? Will he remember his dream?
There was a woodcutter in Cheng who came across a frightened deer in
the country and shot and killed it. Afraid that other people might
see it before he could bring it home, he hid it in a grove and covered
it with chopped wood and branches, and was greatly delighted. Soon
afterwards, however, he forgot where he had hid the deer, and believed
it must have all happened in a dream. As a dream, he told it to
everybody in the streets. Now among the listeners there was one
who heard the story of his dream and went to search for the concealed
deer and found it. He brought the deer home and told his wife,
‘There is a woodcutter who dreamed he had killed a deer and forgot where
he hid it, and here I have found it. He is really a dreamer!’
‘You must have dreamed yourself that you saw a woodcutter who had
killed a deer. Do you really believe that there was a real
woodcutter? But now, you have really got a deer, so your dream
must have been a true one,’ said his wife.
‘Even if I’ve found this deer by a dream,’ answered the husband,
‘what’s the use of worrying whether it is he who was dreaming or I?’
That night, the woodcutter went home, still thinking of his deer, and
he really had a dream, and in that dream, he dreamed back the place of
hiding of the deer and also of its finder. Early at dawn, he went
to the finder’s house and found the deer there. The two then had a
dispute and they went to a judge to settle it. And the judge said
to the woodcutter:
‘You really killed a deer and thought it was a dream. Then you
really had a dream and thought it was reality. He really found the
deer and is now disputing with you about it, but his wife thinks he had
dreamt that he had found a deer shot by someone else. Hence no one
really shot the deer. Since we have the deer before our eyes, you
may divide it between you two.’
The story was brought to the ears of the King of Cheng, and the King
said, ‘Ah, ah! Isn’t the judge dreaming again that he is dividing
the deer for people!’
Our whole life is an attempt to discover when our spontaneity is whimsical,
sentimental irresponsibility and when it is a valid expression of our deepest
desires and values.
Walk with your eyes closed. Hold a friend’s hand and walk long enough that you become
sensitized to the sounds in your ears and textures under your feet.
Ask your friend to put your hand on objects that may be familiar of unfamiliar by sight.
Try not simply to identify them, but to experience them anew.
Walk on your own with your eyes closed for 10 steps, then blink your eyes open
for a snapshot sufficient to sustain you another 10.
Increase to 15, then 20 steps or more.
Sense impending objects with subtle changes in the sound ambiance.
Navigate a mile or more this way, and use the technique to play with your sense of place
and continuity of your environment.
Go for a summer walk through the woods on a moonless night.
— Josh Mitteldorf
3 August 2008
A Moment’s Indulgence
I ask for a moment’s indulgence to sit by thy side.
The works
that I have in hand I will finish afterwards.
Away from the sight of thy face my heart knows no rest nor respite,
and my work becomes an endless toil in a shoreless sea of toil.
Today the summer has come at my window with its sighs and murmurs; and
the bees are plying their minstrelsy at the court of the flowering grove.
Now it is time to sit quiet, face to face with thee, and to sing
dedication of life in this silent and overflowing leisure.
— Rabindranath Tagore
2 August 2008
Brahms is known as the most serious and intellectual of the
19th Century romantic composers. Schoenberg has a reputation for
being cerebral. (Some would say that his music works better for
analysis than listening.) But this Gypsy dance is pure fun.
It was composed by Brahms in 1861 as part of a piano quartet,
orchestrated by Schoenberg in 1937.
About his motivation for transcribing the piece, Schoenberg wrote: ‘I
like the piece. It is seldom played. It is always very badly
played, because the better the pianist, the louder he plays and you hear
nothing from the strings. I wanted for once to hear everything,
and this I achieved.’
“I’ve learned that practical solutions to extreme poverty can only
come from listening to poor people themselves.”
— Paul Polak is a retired
psychiatrist who has devoted himself to the problems of poverty in the
third world. He develops small, ‘obvious’ solutions and finds
ways to reproduce them sustainably.
Interview in Smithsonian magazine.
Video
introduction
Virtually all ‘dollar-a-day’ people in rural areas own their own
houses. But the walls are made of mud and wattle, usually there’
s a
thatched roof, and the floor is a mixture of dung and clay. The house
has no value. You can’
t sell it and, even more critically, you can’
t go
to a bank and use it [as collateral] for a loan. But for $100 you can
build a 20-square-meter house—a skeleton of eight beams and a good roof
that they can add bricks or cinder blocks to. Then they can go to the
bank and borrow against it.
31 July 2008
Radical Christianity
“Jesus taught no theology whatever…there is no warrant in his
teaching for the setting up of any form of ecclesiasticism, of any
hierarchy of officials or system or ritual... All through his public
life he was at war with the ecclesiastics and other religious officials
of his own country…
“Jesus…made a special point of discouraging the laying of emphasis upon
outer observances; and, indeed, upon hard-and-fast rules and regulations
of every kind. What he insisted upon was a certain spirit in one’
s
conduct, and he was careful to teach principles only, knowing that when
the spirit is right, details will take care of themselves; and that, in
fact, ‘the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.’”
— Emmet Fox, born this day in 1876, emulated Jesus in devising
his own religious thought.
30 July 2008
Improvisation for Angular Momentum
Perhaps the death mother like the birth mother
does not desert us but comes to tend
and produce us, to make room for us
and bear us tenderly, considerately,
through the gates, to see us through,
to ease our pains, quell our cries,
to hover over and nestle us, to deliver
us into the greatest, most enduring
peace, all the way past the bother of
recollection,
beyond the finework of frailty,
the mishmash house of the coming & going,
creation’s fringes,
the eddies and curlicues
“Say that a man has been hunting. He must not come home and announce
like a braggart, ‘I have killed a big one in the bush!’ He must
first sit down in silence until I or someone else comes up to his fire
and asks, ‘What did you see today?’ He replies quietly,
‘Ah, I’m no good for hunting. I saw nothing at all…maybe just a
tiny one.’ Then I smile to myself because I now know that he has
killed something big.’ The jesting continues when they go to
retrieve the dead animal: ‘You mean to say you have dragged us all the
way out here to make us cart home your pile of bones? Oh, if I had
known it was this thin, I wouldn’t have come. People, to think I
gave up a nice day in the shade for this. At home we may be hungry
but at least we have nice cool water to drink.’
“When a young man kills much meat, he comes to think of himself as a
chief or a big man, and he thinks the rest of us as his servants or
inferiors. We can’t accept this. We refuse one who boasts,
for someday his pride will make him kill somebody. So we always
speak of his meat as worthless. In this way we cool his heart and
make him gentle.”
Wilson makes a case that egalitarian cooperation is what
distinguishes human societies from the great apes, who socialize in
dominance groups. He cites other tribes with strong sharing
imperatives, where each member is valued equally, and all food is shared
without regard to its origin.
Humans have become exquisitely adapted for close cooperation, for
reading each other’s intentions and emotions, for shunning or punishing
those who cheat or take more than their share. Cooperation, not
intelligence, is the source of our breakout as the most successful
primate.
Historically, it is the most democratic cultures that have
flourished. Social forces within each nation or tribe lead toward
authoritarian regimes with strong dominance; but when groups become
repressive, they fall behind in the competition with more egalitarian
tribes or nations, and thus is democracy maintained and advanced.
28 July 2008
Help me finish this one...
What do you call a skeptic who has lost his faith in atheism?
— Josh Mitteldorf
27 July 2008
What does it take to remind us that the familiar is not
ordinary?
Humans have an uncanny ability to domesticate everything they touch.
Eventually, even the strangest things become absorbed into the routine of the daily mind
with its steady geographies of endurance, anxiety and contentment. Only seldom does the haze lift, and we glimpse for a second, the amazing plenitude of being here. Sometimes, unfortunately, it is suffering or threat that awakens us.
It could happen that one evening, you are busy with many things, netted into your role and the phone rings. Someone you love is suddenly in the grip of an illness that could end their life within hours. It only takes a few seconds to receive that news. Yet, when you put the phone down, you are already standing in a different world. All you know has just been rendered unsure and dangerous.
You realise that the ground has turned into quicksand. Now it seems to you that even mountains are suspended on strings.
Anything worth doing will always have some fear attached to it. For
example, having a baby, getting married, changing careers-all of these
life changes can bring up deep fears. It helps to remember that this
type of fear is good. It is your way of questioning whether you really
want the new life these changes will bring. It is also a potent reminder
that releasing and grieving the past is a necessary part of moving into
the new.
Fear has a way of throwing us off balance, making us feel uncertain and
insecure, but it is not meant to discourage us. Its purpose is to notify
us that we are at the edge of our comfort zone, poised in between the
old life and a new one. Whenever we face our fear, we overcome an inner
obstacle and move into new and life-enhancing territory, both inside and
out. The more we learn to respect and even welcome fear, the more we
will be able to hear its wisdom, wisdom that will let us know that the
time has come to move forward, or not. While comfort with fear is a
contradiction in terms, we can learn to honor our fear, recognizing its
arrival, listening to its intelligence, and respecting it as a harbinger
of transformation. Indeed, it informs us that the change we are
contemplating is significant, enabling us to approach it with the proper
reverence.
«C’est quelque chose, le rire : c’est le dédain et la compréhension mêlés, et
en somme la plus haute manière de voir la vie.»
“Consider laughter: it can be disdain; it can be misapprehension;
but at its best, it is the highest attitude toward life.”
— Gustave Flaubert
Ironie: Lassen Sie sich nicht von ihr beherrschen, besonders nicht in unschöpferischen Momenten.
In schöpferischen versuchen Sie es, sich ihrer zu bedienen, als eines Mittels mehr, das Leben zu fassen.
Rein gebraucht, ist sie auch rein, und man muß sich ihrer nicht schämen;
und fühlen Sie sich ihr zu vertraut, fürchten Sie die wachsende Vertraulichkeit mit ihr,
dann wenden Sie sich an große und ernste Gegenstände, vor denen sie klein und hilflos wird.
Suchen Sie die Tiefe der Dinge: dort steigt Ironie nie hinab, —
und wenn Sie 50 an den Rand des Großen führen, erproben Sie gleichzeitig,
ob diese Auffassungsart einer Notwendigkeit Ihres Wesens entspringt.
Denn unter dem Einfluß ernster Dinge wird sie entweder von Ihnen abfallen (wenn sie etwas Zufälliges ist),
oder aber sie wird (so sie wirklich eingeboren Ihnen zugehört) erstarken zu einem ernsten Werkzeug und sich
einordnen in die Reihe der Mittel, mit denen Sie Ihre Kunst werden bilden müssen.
Irony: Don’t let yourself be controlled by it, especially during uncreative moments.
When you are fully creative, try to use it as one more way to take hold of life. Used purely, it too is pure,
and one needn’t be ashamed of it;
but if you feel yourself becoming too familiar with it, if you are afraid of this growing familiarity, then turn to great and serious objects,
before which it becomes small and helpless.
Search into the depths of things: there, irony never descends - and when you arrive at the edge of greatness,
find out whether this way of perceiving the world arises from a necessity of your being.
For under the influence of serious things it will either fall away from you (if it is something accidental),
or else (if it is really innate and belongs to you) it will grow strong,
and become a serious tool and take its place among the instruments with which you can form your art.
— Rainer Maria Rilke
24 July 2008
Art as deliverance from alienation
«Celui qui, souvent, a choisi son destin d'artiste parce qu'il se sentait différent
apprend bien vite qu'il ne nourrira son art, et sa différence,
qu'en avouant sa ressemblance avec tous.»
“Often he who has chosen the fate of the artist because he felt
himself to be different soon realizes that he can maintain neither his
art nor his difference unless he admits that he is like the others.”
«Le véritable voyage de découverte ne consiste pas à chercher de
nouveaux paysages, mais à avoir de nouveaux yeux.»
“The real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new
landscapes but having new eyes”
— Marcel Proust
22 July 2008
“The best way to find out if you can trust somebody is to trust him.”
— Ernest Hemmingway, born this day in 1899
21 July 2008
Separating fear from the apprehension of danger
All during my childhood, I had nightmares about nuclear holocaust.
The dreams were not all the same, but in each one there was a gathering
apprehension of distant missiles, followed by increasing certainty that
a missile was nigh. Then I would hear the explosion or see the
mushroom cloud and I would know that this moment was my last…just as I
awoke, heart pounding within my chest.
The dreams continued through adolescence and young adulthood, even as
some waking consciousness crept in: As the certainty of my doom
came upon me, I would remember, ‘The last time I experienced this, it
turned out I was dreaming. Could it be that this, too, is a
dream?’
I matured. I learned to separate thoughts from the feelings
that accompany them, and learned to identify emotions with physical
sensations within me. One morning (I was 26), I dozed off
during deep relaxation following yoga asanas. I was in a dream of
nuclear terror, but simultaneously I was aware of lying safely on the
floor of my yoga room. I experienced terror as a physical sensation, a
mushrooming hollow within my chest that spread outward through my limbs.
I was overwhelmed with terror; I knew I was safe.
I have not since then had nightmares of nuclear annihilation.
— Josh Mitteldorf
20 July 2008
A century before Rosa Parks
A black woman refused to give up her seat on a bus. She was
brutally attacked and thrown off...and she took the case to court.
It was the summer of 1854, and her name was
Elizabeth Jennings.
Here’s how the The New York Tribune reported the Jennings incident in a
February 1855 article: “She got upon one of the Company’s cars last
summer, on the Sabbath, to ride to church. The conductor undertook to
get her off, first alleging the car was full; when that was shown to be
false, he pretended the other passengers were displeased at her
presence; but (when) she insisted on her rights, he took hold of her by
force to expel her. She resisted. The conductor got her down on the
platform, jammed her bonnet, soiled her dress and injured her person.
Quite a crowd gathered, but she effectually resisted. Finally, after the
car had gone on further, with the aid of a policeman they succeeded in
removing her.”
Jennings sued the company, the driver, and the conductor. Messrs. Culver, Parker,
and Arthur represented her. Arthur was Chester A. Arthur, then a novice 21-year-old
lawyer and future President of the United States. This law firm was hired because it
had demonstrated some talent in the area of civil rights the year before.
Elizabeth Jennings claimed $500 worth of damage. The majority of the jury
wanted to give her the full amount, but, as the Tribune put it, "Some jury members
had peculiar notions as to colored people's rights." They eventually agreed to give
her $225, and the court added 10% plus her expenses.
Within a month of the Jennings decision, an African American
named Peter Porter was barred from an Eighth Avenue rail car. He too sued and the company
settled out of court. From then on, African Americans were allowed to ride on
New York rail cars on an equal basis.
Social insects are arguably the most successful animal group ever to
appear in evolutionary history. They derive their power from
division of labor and a genetic program of behaviors that subjugate the
welfare of the individual for the benefit of the colony.
18 July 2008
The Creed of my Heart
The rose-lit clouds of morning; the sun-kissed
mountain heights;
The orient streaks and flushes; the mingling
shades and lights;
The flow of the lonely river; the voice of its
distant stream;
The mists that rise from the meadows, lit up by
the sun’s first beam;—
They mingle and melt as I watch them; melt and
mingle and die.
The land is one with the water: the earth is one
with the sky.
The parts are as parts no longer: Nature is All
and One:
Her life is achieved, completed: her days of waiting are done.
“Common experience shows how much rarer is moral courage than
physical bravery. A thousand men will march to the mouth of the cannon
where one man will dare espouse an unpopular cause . . . True courage
comes from a consciousness of the right attitude toward the
world, a faith in one’s purpose, and the sufficiency of one’s own
approval as justification for one’s own acts.”