Questioning--the Key to Understanding

Questioning Myths

Home | Uses & Types | Teachers & Q | Students & Q | Classroom | Shared Inquiry | Myths | Educator tip sheet | Etiquette Do's | Etiquette Don'ts | Classroom applications | TEKS | Standards | Bibliography | Webliography

Myths about questioning
Wilen (2001) discusses nine myths about questioning students that I found very pertinent.

Myth 1: Questioning is a natural teaching behavior that does not require planning.
He explains that even the most experienced teacher needs to plan questions in order to have thoughtful, meaningful, and effective discussions.

Myth 2: The more questions the teacher asks, the more students will learn.
Teachers ask too many questions. Ask fewer higher order thinking questions that evoke more discussion.

Myth 3: There are no bad questions.
Questions need to be clear and purposeful—not intimidating or lacking in direction.

Myth 4: Higher-level cognitive questions are more critical than lower-level questions.
For preparation of higher-level questions and recall of information, lower-level questions are appropriate. All level questions are important, but they need to fit with the objective of what the teacher is doing.

Myth 5: Higher-level cognitive questions elicit higher-level answers.
Don’t count on it. That happens about half of the time. Teachers need to train to students to respond at the higher level.

Myth 6: Teachers should ask lower-level cognitive questions before progressing to higher-level questions.
Higher-level questions can be asked at the beginning of a unit to spark the students’ interest.

Myth 7: Teachers give students enough time to answer questions.
His data said teachers wait an average of 1 second and waiting at least 3 second will yield better responses. Other information I gathered recommended 10 seconds (Johnson, 1995).

Myth 8: When questioning students, teachers should call only on volunteering students.
Teachers shouldn’t embarrass students, but all student need to participate. Teachers need to device a method of making sure all students are given the opportunity to enter a discussion.

Myth 9: Teachers encourage students to ask questions.
Sadly, teachers dominate the talk in the classroom—many talk 75 percent of the time—and don’t encourage student inquiry.
(Wilen, 2001)

Contact me: sestepp@verizon.net