League Champions and Post-Season Play

• 1951 Rotary (N); no American League
  
• 1952 Rotary (N) def. Elks (A), 4-0
  
• 1953 Pastore (N); Elks (A); no records available
  
• 1954 Rotary (N); Lions (A); Town Series not held
  
• 1955 Rotary (N) def. Legion (A), 4-2, 10-0
  
• 1956 Elks (A) def. Pastore (N), 7-2, 1-0
  
• 1957 Rotary (N) def. Pasquin (A), 2-0, 7-6 (7 inn.)
  
• 1958 Rotary (N) def. Pasquin (A), 3-1
  
• 1959 Pasquin (A) def. Kiwanis (N), 4-3 (7 inn.)
  
• 1960 Kiwanis (N) def. Legion (A), 5-10, 5-2, 6-0
  
• 1961 Kiwanis (N) def. Lions (A), 2 games to ?
  
• 1962 Flash (A) def. Rotary (N), 3-1, 12-0
  
• 1963 Jones (N) def. Flash (A), 3-1, 9-3
  
• 1964 Gilio (N) def. Keller (A), 7-3, 0-2, 11-3
  
• 1965 Gilio (N) def. Lions (A), 3-1, 7-0
  
• 1966 Kiwanis (N) def. Keller (A), 3-2, 9-0
  
• 1967 Rotary (N) def. Lions (A), 3-2, 8-0
  
• 1968 Sifford (N) def. Legion (A), 2-0, 1-7, 4-0
  
• 1969 Sifford (N) def. Flash (A), 2-1, 2-9, 3-1
  
• 1970 Flash (A) def. Sifford (N), 4-2, 6-2
  
• 1971 Lions (A) def. Altman (N), 6-6 (tie), 11-10, 14-7
  
• 1972 Rotary (N) def. Keller (A), 2 games to 0
  
• 1973 Flash (A) def. Kiwanis (N), 14-13, 10-9
  
• 1974 Flash (A) def. Kiwanis (N), 3-2 (7 inn.), 4-3
  
• 1975 Flash (A) def. Critchley (N), 11-1, 2-4, 5-2 (7 inn.)
  
• 1976 Springs (N) def. Flash (A), 5-6, 11-10, 3-2 (7 inn.)
  
• 1977 Roadrunner (A) def. Springs (N), 3-2, 8-7
  
• 1978 Elks (A) def. Springs (N), 4-6, 2-0, 8-4
  
• 1979 Elks (A) def. Kiwanis (N), 8-2, 4-0 (8 inn.)
  
• 1980 Kiwanis (N) def. Flash (A), 8-3, 4-3
• 1981 Kiwanis (N) def. Roadrunner (A), 6-0, 2-1
• 1982 Kiwanis (N) def. Keller (A), 3-1, 10-7
• 1983 Altman (N) def. Keller (A), 2-1, 5-3
• 1984 Elks (A) def. Kurgan (N), 11-0, 5-2
• 1985 Elks (A) def. Kurgan (N), 9-1, 4-0
  
• 1986
  Naborhood (AL-W) def. Tommy's (AL-E), 4-3, 4-7, 7-4
  Rotary (NL-W) def. Kiwanis (NL-E), 5-4 (7 inn.), 16-3
  Naborhood (A) def. Rotary (N), 4-3
• 1987
  Tommy's (AL-E) def. Naborhood (AL-W), 9-0, 19-1
  Rotary (NL-E) def. Kurgan (NL-W), 8-4, 7-9, 1-0 (8 inn.)
  Tommy's (A) def. Rotary (N), 5-2
• 1988
  Keller (AL-E) def. Naborhood (AL-W), 11-9, 13-5
  Park (NL-W) def. R.S.G. (NL-E), 16-5, 9-8
  Keller (A) def. Park (N), 15-6
• 1989
  Keller (AL-E) def. Lions (AL-W), 5-4, 21-7
  Park (NL-E) def. Kurgan (NL-W), 8-4 (8 inn.), 8-1
  Park (N) def. Keller (A), 5-4
• 1990
  Lions (AL-W) def. Flash (AL-E), 6-1, 7-4
  R.S.G. (NL-E) def. Rotary (NL-W), 8-3 (8 inn.), 9-1
  R.S.G. (N) def. Lions (A), 11-7
• 1991
  Naborhood (AL-W) def. Elks (AL-E), 7-13 (9 inn.), 11-0, 7-4
  Rotary (NL-W) def. Kiwanis (NL-E), 12-4, 6-1
  Rotary (N) def. Naborhood (A), 6-1
• 1992
  Lions (AL-W) def. Keller (AL-E), 1-0, 14-4
  Kiwanis (NL-E) def. Kurgan (NL-W), 5-4 (9 inn.), 7-9, 2-1
  Lions (A) def. Kiwanis (N), 6-1
• 1993
  Lions (AL-W) def. Keller (AL-E), 4-3, 5-1
  Kiwanis (NL-E) def. Springs (NL-W), 10-0, 10-4
  Kiwanis (N) def. Lions (A), 4-2
• 1994
  Naborhood (A3) def. Lions (A2), 10-3; Naborhood def. Elks (A1), 6-1
  Fire (N2) def. Springs (N3), 8-7; Kurgan (N1) def. Fire, 6-5
  Kurgan (N1) def. Naborhood (A3), 3-1, 12-3
• 1995
  Naborhood (A2) def. Tommy's (A3), 3-2; Flash (A1) def. Naborhood, 7-6
  Fire (N2) def. Kurgan (N3), 5-4; Springs (N1) def. Fire, 6-5
  Flash (A1) def. Springs (N1), 5-4
• 1996
  Lions (A2) def. Tommy's (A3), 13-2; Keller (A1) def. Lions, 6-3
  Springs (N3t) def. Kurgan (N3t), 8-2 (7 inn.); Fire (N2) def. Springs, 16-8; Rotary (N1) def. Fire, 16-3
  Keller (A1) def. Rotary (N1), 4-2
• 1997
  Lions (A3t) def. Tommy's (A3t), 14-5; Keller (A2) def. Lions, 6-5; Naborhood (A1) def. Keller, 4-3 (7 inn.)
  Springs (N3) def. Rotary (N2), 9-3; Fire (N1) def. Springs, 12-0
  Fire (N1) def. Naborhood (A1), 6-5 (7 inn.)
• 1998
  Lions (A2t) def. Naborhood (A2t), 5-4; Keller (A1) def. Lions, 6-2
  Springs (N2) def. Kiwanis (N3), 9-8; Springs def. Fire (N1), 6-2
  Keller (A1) def. Springs (N2), 1-0
• 1999
  Flash (A3t) def. Elks (A3t), 6-5; DiNoto (A2) def. Flash, 10-3; Lions (A1) def. DiNoto, 7-6 (7 inn.)
  Kiwanis (N2) def. Inline (N3), 11-2; Kiwanis def. Kurgan (N1), 4-1
  Lions (A1) def. Kiwanis (N2), 6-0
• 2000
  Keller (A2) def. Tommy's (A3), 5-4; Elks (A1) def. Keller, 4-3
  Kurgan (N3) def. Inline (N2), 8-7; Kiwanis (N1) def. Kurgan, 9-2
  Elks (A1) def. Kiwanis (N1), 6-0
• 2001
  Keller (A2) def. DiNoto (A3), 8-7; Keller def. Elks (A1), 3-2
  Kiwanis (N2t) def. Springs (N2t), 4-2; Fire (N1) def. Kiwanis, 4-2
  Keller (A2) def. Fire (N1), 10-6
• 2002
  Flash (A3) def. Lions (A2), 1-0; Flash def. Tancredi (A1), 5-1
  P.B.A. (N3) def. Inline (N2), 4-3; Fire (N1) def. P.B.A., 11-1
  Flash (A3) def. Fire (N1), 2-1
• 2003
  Keller (A3) def. Flash (A2), 1-0; Lions (A1) def. Keller, 7-3
  Fire (N3) def. Springs (N2), 3-2; Fire def. V.F.W. (N1), 6-4
  Lions (A1) def. Fire (N3), 4-3 (8 inn.)
• 2004
  Keller (A2) def. Flash (A3), 4-1; Lions (A1) def. Keller, 4-3
  Springs (N3) def. V.F.W. (N2), 3-2; Springs def. Kiwanis (N1), 4-2
  Lions (A1) def. Springs (N3), 3-0
• 2005
  Flash (A3) def. Lions (A2), 1-0; Keller (A1) def. Flash, 3-2
  Kurgan (N3) def. P.B.A. (N2), 8-4; Kurgan def. Van Winkle (N1), 11-9
  Keller (A1) def. Kurgan (N3), 3-1
• 2006
  DiNoto (A3) def. Keller (A2), 4-2; Flash (A1) def. DiNoto, 10-6
  Fire (N3t) def. P.B.A. (N3t), 7-2; Fire def. Springs (N2), 6-5; Van Winkle (N1) def. Fire, 6-3
  Van Winkle (N1) def. Flash (A1), 5-4
• 2007
  Tancredi (A2) def. Elks (A3), 5-2; Keller (A1) def. Tancredi, 7-6
  Springs (N2) def. Fire (N3), 2-1; Van Winkle (N1) def. Springs, 4-2
  Van Winkle (N1) def. Keller (A1), 3-1 (8 inn.)
• 2008
  Lions (A2) def. Cedola (A3), 7-2; Keller (A1) def. Lions, 5-1
  P.B.A. (N3t) def. Kurgan (N3t), 2-1; V.F.W. (N2) def. P.B.A., 12-5; V.F.W. def. Fire (N1), 2-1
  Keller (A1) def. V.F.W. (N2), 9-6

Note: Through 1985, league champions met in best-of-3 series (except 1958 and 1959, when it was a single game). From 1986 to 1993, each league was split into two three-team divisions. Divisional winners played best-of-3, and survivors met in one-game final. Starting in 1994, top 3 teams in each league (plus ties, indicated by 3t) qualified for single-elimination playoffs. In 1994 only, final was best-of-3.