| American League | National League |
| Elks | Boiling Springs Savings |
| Flash Cleaners | Fire Department |
| Keller-Depken Oil | Kiwanis |
| Lions | Kurgan-Bergen Realtors |
| Naborhood Pharmacy | Rotary |
| Tommy's Towing | Rutherford Sports |
| American League | National League |
| Boiling Spring Masonic Lodge | Rutherford Engine Co. 4 |
| DiNoto Fuel Oil | Tancredi Plumbing |
| Goffin's | V.F.W. Post 227 |
| Ellwood S. New | Justin Insurance |
| P.B.A. Local 300 | Mama Rosa Pizzeria |
| American League | National League |
| The Bank of New York | Ridge Service |
| Carol's Corner | Roy Rogers |
| M & R Meats & Deli | West End Fire Co. 3 |
| D & D Deli | Cedola's Auto Repair |
| P.J. Obiedzinski, D.P.M. | Century 21 A.W. Van Winkle |
| 1994 | 1995 | 1996 |
|---|---|---|
| History | History | History |
| Standings | Standings | Standings |
| Teams | Teams | Teams |
| Leaders | Leaders | Leaders |
| Tourney | Tourney | Tourney |