The Law and Flags at Sea
On this page:
The flag of the United States was first adopted by resolution of the Continental Congress, June 14, 1777:
Resolved, That the flag of the thirteen United States be thirteen stripes, alternate red and white: that the union be thirteen stars, white in a blue field, representing a new constellation.This 13-star, 13-stripe design remained in effect until 1795, when two additional stars and stripes were added to mark the admission to the Union of Vermont and Kentucky. From that point on, it was unchanged, despite the admission of further states, until 1818, when the number had reached 20. After much debate, Congress decided to abandon the idea of adding a stripe for each new state and instead adopted the law that determines the design of the flag today:
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America, in Congress assembled, That from and after the fourth day of July next, the flag of the United States be thirteen horizontal stripes, alternate red and white: that the union be twenty stars, white in a blue field.Although it has been reenacted several times in connection with the codification of federal statutes (most recently in 1947), the substance of the 1818 law is still in effect and may be found in Title 4, United States Code, Sections 1 and 2:
Sec. 2. And be it further enacted, That on the admission of every new state into the Union, one star be added to the union of the flag; and that such addition shall take effect on the fourth day of July then next succeeding such admission.
Act of April 4, 1818, ch. 34, 3 Stat. 415
Sec. 1. Flag; stripes and stars on. The flag of the United States shall be thirteen horizontal stripes, alternate red and white; and the union of the flag shall be forty-eight stars, white in a blue field.
Sec. 2. Same; additional stars. On the admission of a new State into the Union one star shall be added to the union of the flag; and such addition shall take effect on the fourth day of July then next succeeding such admission.
It may be noted that the statute gives relatively little guidance on the precise design of the flag: the correct proportions between hoist and fly, the size of the canton (union), the arrangement of the stars, the shades of red and blue, or even whether the stripes are seven red and six white or vice versa. Traditionally, there was great variety in these aspects of flag design, with only the Navy, Army, and federal civilian departments subject to more precise regulation, which they issued in the form of departmental orders and directives. The earliest of these was a circular from the Board of Navy Commissioners in 1818 prescribing the arrangement of the stars and the sequence of the stripes for the 20-star ensign enacted by Congress that year. In the early 20th century, several officers noted the desirability of a single standard design and a set of standard flag sizes for government use, and in 1912 President Taft issued an executive order setting 10:19 as the standard ratio for hoisted flags and prescribing the precise sizes and arrangements of the flag's component parts. Since then, each time a new state is admitted, a new executive order is issued, the one currently in effect being President Eisenhower's Executive Order No. 10834 of August. 21, 1959. The color shades used in flags procured for government and military use are set by a federal procurement specification issued by the General Services Administration.
There is some question whether the requirements of the executive order apply outside the Executive Branch of the Federal Government. In 1998, Congress added to the Flag Code (Title 4, U.S. Code, Sec. 5 et seq) the proviso that "The flag of the United States for the purpose of this chapter shall be defined according to sections 1 and 2 of this title and Executive Order 10834 issued pursuant thereto." But this language on its face would rule most actual U.S. flags out of coverage by the Flag Code, since very few flags in public use conform to the 10:19 proportions set by the Executive Order. Clearly Congress cannot have intended that due respect and honor need not be paid to a Stars and Stripes manufactured in four by six or three by five foot sizes. I conclude from this that, notwithstanding this addition to the Code, private citizens and agencies outside the Federal Executive Branch remain at liberty to use flags of any design consistent with the terms of the 1818 law if they so desire.Return to top of page
The display of national flags on the high seas is regulated by customary international law, articles 90-94 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (to which the United States is not a party), and article 5 of the 1958 Geneva Convention on the High Seas, "each State shall fix the conditions for the grant of its nationality to ships, for the registration of ships in its territory, and for the right to fly its flag." Further, "each State shall issue to ships to which it has granted the right to fly its flag documents to that effect." Flying a country's flag constitutes a claim by the vessel flying it that it possesses the nationality of the flag (NWP 1-14M, The Commander's Handbook on the Law of Naval Operations), and therefore, as the U.S. District Court for Oregon ruled in the case of The Fideliter in 1869, "it is of importance to all maritime powers that the national character borne by a ship [i.e., in the flag she displays] should be her true character" (8 F.Cas. 1177). Accordingly, most countries have implemented the obligations in the by explicit legislation.
Return to top of page
Unlike most other countries, the right of American ships and boats to fly the American flag is not explicitly spelled out by law or regulation. It stems rather from a combination of the laws determining what constitutes a vessel with American nationality, judicial precedent, and the customary international law that gives vessels of a particular nationality the right to display that flag.
The first law governing the nationality of vessels in the United States, "An Act for Registering and Clearing Vessels" (1 Stat. 55) was enacted on September 1, 1789. It provided that only a ship built in the United States, owned by an American citizen, and under the command of an American master could be registered, and being registered "shall be deemed and taken to be, and denominated, a ship or vessel of the United States." Three years later, "An Act Concerning the Registering and Recording of Ships or Vessels" (1 Stat. 287) added that registered vessels of the United States were "entitled to the benefits and privileges appertaining to such ships or vessels." Under customary international law, one of those privileges is flying the United States flag.
Under the current statutory authority on documentation of American vessels, the Vessel Documentation Act of 1980, ships and boats of more than five measurement tons are eligible to be documented by the U.S. Coast Guard. The Coast Guard considers that documentation to provide authoritative evidence of a vessel's U.S. nationality. Not all vessels over five tons are required to be documented, however; those not involved in trade are exempt.
What, then, of the right to fly the flag aboard undocumented vessels, whether above or below the five-ton threshold? The Assistant Attorney General of the United States, arguing the case of Billings v. United States before the Supreme Court in 1914, stated that "A yacht belonging to a citizen of the United States, even though not a vessel of the United States in the sense that it is entitled to registry or enrollment, yet flies the American flag, and is the object of peculiar protection by the United States" (232 U.S. 261). Furthermore, the right of free expression guaranteed by the first amendment to the Constitution would also guarantee to any U.S. citizen the right to fly the American (or any other) flag.
Return to top of page
During wartime, if a vessel operates under an enemy flag, it by definition possesses "enemy character" and may be attacked as an enemy ship. By contrast, flying a neutral ship is not a definitive proof of a ship's neutral character, as an enemy ship may be flying a neutral flag as a ruse. For this reason, one of the rights of a belligerent warship is the right of "visit and search." There are specific rules on how this right is exercised, including the requirement that the warship exercising the right hoist its national flag before summoning the suspect vessel to lie to for boarding. If a neutral merchant ship, the summoned vessel is required to follow instructions and display her colors as well. If it is in fact an enemy ship and tries to get away, it is subject to attack. Refusing to heed the instructions of a warship under these conditions is tantamount to an admission of enemy status and entitles the warship to use force.
As in the days of sail, an enemy warship signals its readiness to surrender by "striking its colors," that is, hauling down her national ensign. Once an enemy warship "has clearly indicated a readiness to surrender," the attack must be discontinued. One may not fire upon a ship that has struck its colors.
When displayed from any conspicuous place of hoist, [the flag of truce] indicates a desire to send a communication, but the truce does not exist until the hoist has been replied to. A belligerent may decline to receive the flag of truce. If blank guns are fired while a flag of truce is displayed, the ship, boat or party nearing it must stop and not approach nearer. Bearers of the flag of truce are inviolable provided they do not act improperly. Should they do so, or should the flag be used improperly to obtain information, the bearers may become subject to capture and punished as spies.Cartel ships, vessels used to transport exchanged prisoners of war or to carry envoys, are identified by the display of flags as mutually agreed by the belligerent parties. This display normally includes flying the flag of truce at some specified point of hoist on the cartel ship.
Many countries require either as a matter law or of customary practice that foreign vessels in their territorial waters display the host country's flag. This flag is known as a "courtesy ensign." When a host country has a merchant ensign that differs from its national flag used ashore, it is the merchant ensign that is displayed as the courtesy ensign. According to The Commander's Handbook on the Law of Naval Operations, however, "a warship cannot be required . . . to fly the flag of the host nation." U.S. policy is that public vessels, including warships as well as civilian-manned ships belonging to the Military Sealift Command and other U.S. government vessels, enjoy sovereign immune status, that they are exempt from the jurisdiction of any other state. Because complying with a coastal state's regulations purporting to require the display of its flag in its waters or ports could be construed as an admission that the U.S. public vessel is subject to the coastal state's jurisdiction, all U.S. public vessels are forbidden from flying courtesy ensigns.
As described at the page on Navy flag ceremonies, a Navy or Coast Guard ship firing a salute in honor of a foreign country or a foreign officer or dignitary does fly that country's naval ensign at a masthead as prescribed by Navy Regulations. This practice is sometimes misinterpreted as a violation of the U.S. Flag Code, as it seems to involve placing a foreign flag above that of the United States. In fact, the Flag Code has no bearing on naval flag practice; by its own terms the Flag Code applies only to "civilians or civilian groups or organizations as may not be required to conform with regulations promulgated by one or more executive departments of the Government of the United States." Furthermore, the Flag Code speaks of displaying a foreign flag "equal, above, or in a position of superior prominence or honor to, or in place of" the American flag. On a ship, the place of superior prominence and honor is the flagstaff at the stern (when not under way) or the gaff (when under way). Any masthead is a place of inferior honor to either of these. Moreover, both the Coast Guard and the Navy have stated that "above" in the nautical context means at a higher level at the same point of hoist, given the distinctive arrangement of the masts and rigging used for nautical flag display.
As with salutes, a ship that is dressed or full-dressed for a foreign festivity or solemnity flies that country's naval ensign at the head of the mainmast. As with flags displayed for salutes, this practice does not contravene the Flag Code's prohibition against displaying a foreign flag "above" the American flag, whether the ship dressed is a warship or a merchant vessel.
Return to top of page
Return to Sea Flags home page
Copyright 2000, 2001 by Joseph McMillan