| Team | Player Selected | Player Cut | ||
| Ungulates | Dallas Braden | Jose Bautista | ||
| Huskers | Jeremy Affeldt | Freddie Garcia | ||
| Rogues | pass | |||
| Revival | Chan Ho Park | Tim Byrdak | ||
| Cubs | Scott Hairston | Kyle Farnsworth | ||
| Sluggers | Dan Giese | Brian Barton | ||
| Comets | Jose Bautista | Jack Hannahan | ||
| Titans | pass | |||
| Icons | Jeff Mathis | Chad Gaudin | ||
| A's | Brett Gardner | Michael Barrett | ||
| Blackjacks | Ryan Tucker | Pedro Martinez | ||
| Whiz Kids | Willie Harris | Matt Stairs | ||
| Zips | pass | |||
| Ponies | Clayton Richard | Scott Proctor | ||
| Mavs | Emilio Bonifacio | Jeff Kent | ||
| Bombers | Javier Lopez | Ron Mahay | ||
| Baseball | Brian Anderson | Jason Schmidt | ||
| Mitts | Russell Branyan | Dontrelle Willis | ||
| Dream | Matt Harrison | Sergio Romo | ||
| Hurricanes | pass | |||
| Team | Player Selected | Player Cut | ||
| Ungulates | pass | |||
| Huskers | pass | |||
| Rogues | pass | |||
| Revival | Troy Percival | Chris Ray | ||
| Cubs | Adam Kennedy | Jason Bergman | ||
| Sluggers | Aaron Laffey | Jose Veras | ||
| Comets | Rajai Davis | Eric Byrnes | ||
| Titans | pass | |||
| Icons | Doug Mientkiewicz | Craig Counsell | ||
| A's | Darin Erstad | Ross Gload | ||
| Blackjacks | John Buck | Luis Ayala | ||
| Whiz Kids | pass | |||
| Zips | pass | |||
| Ponies | Mike Hampton | Justin Speier | ||
| Mavs | Eugenio Velez | Paul Byrd | ||
| Bombers | Chad Gaudin | Salomon Torres | ||
| Baseball | Saul Rivera | Wladamir Balentien | ||
| Mitts | pass | |||
| Dream | Burke Badenhop | Mike Morse | ||
| Hurricanes | pass | |||